| Offense | | Position | First team | Second team | | Quarterback | George Blanda, Houston Oilers (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI) | Jack Kemp, San Diego Chargers (AFL, NY, UPI) | | Halfback | Billy Cannon, Houston Oilers (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Abner Haynes, Dallas Texans (AFL, NY, SN, UPI) | Paul Lowe, San Diego Chargers (AFL, NY, UPI)
Donnie Stone, Denver Broncos (NY) | | Fullback | Bill Mathis, New York Titans (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI) | Charlie Tolar, Houston Oilers (AFL, UPI)
Alan Miller, Oakland Raiders (NY) | | Wide receiver | Charlie Hennigan, Houston Oilers (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Lionel Taylor, Denver Broncos (AFL, AP, NY, UPI)
Bill Groman, Houston Oilers (AP, SN) | Gino Cappelletti, Boston Patriots (AFL, NY, UPI)
Bill Groman, Houston Oilers (NY, UPI) | | Tackle | Al Jamison, Houston Oilers (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Ron Mix, San Diego Chargers (AFL, AP, NY, UPI)
Jerry Cornelison, Dallas Texans (SN) | Ken Rice, Buffalo Bills (AFL, NY, UPI)
Jerry Cornelison, Dallas Texans (UPI)
Jerry DeLucca, Boston Patriots (AFL)
Ernie Wright, San Diego Chargers (NY) | | Guard | Bob Mischak, New York Titans (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Tony Sardisco, Boston Patriots (NY, UPI)
Ken Adamson, Denver Broncos (AP)
Charley Leo, Boston Patriots (AFL)
Wayne Hawkins, Oakland Raiders (SN) | Ken Adamson, Denver Broncos (AFL, NY, UPI)
Billy Krisher, Dallas Texans (NY, UPI)
Bob Talamini, Houston Oilers (AFL, UPI) | | Center | Jim Otto, Oakland Raiders (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI) | Don Rogers, San Diego Chargers (NY, UPI)
Bob Schmidt, Houston Oilers (AFL) | | | Defense | | Position | First team | Second team | | Defensive end | Earl Faison, San Diego Chargers (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Ron Nery, San Diego Chargers (AP, SN)
LaVerne Torczon, Buffalo Bills (NY, UPI)
Don Floyd, Houston Oilers (AFL) | Ron Nery, San Diego Chargers (AP, SN)
Bob Dee, Boston Patriots (AFL)
Larry Eisenhauer, Boston Patriots (NY)
LaVerne Torczon, Buffalo Bills (AFL)
Sid Youngelman, New York Titans (UPI) | | Defensive tackle | Bud McFadin, Denver Broncos (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Ernie Ladd, San Diego Chargers (AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Chuck McMurtry, Buffalo Bills (AFL) | Bill Hudson, San Diego Chargers (NY, UPI)
Ed Husmann, Houston Oilers (NY, UPI)
Jim Lee Hunt, Boston Patriots (AFL)
Ernie Ladd, San Diego Chargers (AFL) | | Middle linebacker | Sherrill Headrick, Dallas Texans (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Archie Matsos, Buffalo Bills (AFL, NY)
Chuck Allen, San Diego Chargers (AFL) | Chuck Allen, San Diego Chargers (NY)
Archie Matsos, Buffalo Bills (UPI) | | Outside linebacker | Larry Grantham, New York Titans (AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Tom Addison, Boston Patriots (AP, SN, UPI) | E.J. Holub, Dallas Texans (AFL, NY, UPI)
Ralph Felton, Buffalo Bills (UPI)
Larry Grantham, New York Titans (AFL) | | Cornerback | Dick Harris, San Diego Chargers (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Tony Banfield, Houston Oilers (AFL, AP, SN, UPI)
Mark Johnston, Houston Oilers (NY) | Claude Gibson, San Diego Chargers (NY, UPI)
Fred Williamson, Oakland Raiders (AFL, UPI)
Tony Banfield, Houston Oilers (NY) | | Safety | Charlie McNeil, San Diego Chargers, (AFL, AP, NY, SN, UPI)
Bill Atkins, Buffalo Bills (NY, SN, UPI)
Dave Webster, Dallas Texans (AFL, AP) | Goose Gonsoulin, Denver Broncos (AFL, UPI)
Jim Norton, Houston Oilers (NY, UPI)
Bill Atkins, Buffalo Bills (AFL)
Dick Felt, New York Titans (AFL)
Ross O'Hanley, Boston Patriots (NY) | |
French
Deutsch