2019 Samoa measles outbreak

2019 Samoa measles outbreak
Disease	Measles
Virus strain	D8 strain (genotype) of measles virus[1]
Index case	30 September 2019
Dates	30 September 2019 – 22 December 2019[2]
Confirmed cases	5,707[3]
Deaths	83[4]
Government website
http://www.samoagovt.ws/

The 2019 Samoa measles outbreak began in September 2019.^[5] As of 6 January 2020, there were over 5,700 cases of measles and 83 deaths, out of a Samoan population of 200,874.^[4][6] Over three per cent of the population were infected.^[7] The cause of the outbreak was attributed to decreased vaccination rates among newly born babies, from 74% in 2017 to 31–34% in 2018, even though nearby islands had rates near 99%.

A state of emergency was declared on 17 November, ordering the closure of all schools, keeping children under 17 away from public events, and vaccination became mandatory. On 2 December 2019, the government imposed a curfew and cancelled all Christmas celebrations and public gatherings. Families seeking MMR vaccination were asked by the government to display an item of red cloth in front of their homes so as to alert mobile medical teams traveling the island during the lockdown.^[8] Some added messages like "Help!" or "I want to live!".^[9] On 5 and 6 December, the government shut down everything to bring civil servants over to the vaccination campaign. This curfew was lifted on 7 December when the government estimated that the vaccination program had reached 90% of the population. On 14 December, the state of emergency was extended to 29 December.^[10] Samoan anti-vaccination activist Edwin Tamasese was arrested and charged with "incitement against a government order". Finally, as of 22 December 2019, an estimated 94% of the eligible population had been vaccinated.^[7]

Measles first arrived in Samoa in 1893, carried by a steamer from New Zealand. By the end of 1893, over 1,000 people (of a total population of 34,500 at that time) had died from the disease.^[11]

In 2019 there were outbreaks throughout the Pacific region, including in Tonga, Fiji, the Philippines and New Zealand,^[12][13][14] but only Samoa suffered casualties, due to its low vaccination rate.^[15]

The outbreak is attributed to Samoa's sharp drop in measles vaccination from the previous year.^[16]

In 2013, 90% of babies in Samoa received the measles-mumps-rubella vaccination at one year of age.^[9]

On 6 July 2018 on the east coast of Savai'i, two 12-month-old children died after receiving MMR vaccinations.^[8] The cause of death was incorrect preparation of the vaccine by two nurses who mixed vaccine powder with expired anaesthetic instead of the appropriate diluent.^[17] These two deaths were picked up by anti-vaccine groups and used to incite fear towards vaccination on social media, causing the government to suspend its measles vaccination programme for ten months, despite advice from the WHO.^[18][16] The incident caused many Samoan residents to lose trust in the healthcare system.^[19] From October 1, 2018, through late November 2018, UNICEF provided 115,500 measles vaccines doses to Samoa (including the diluent, syringes and safety boxes), and also shipped Vitamin A supplies.^[20][21] UNICEF and the World Health Organization estimate that the measles vaccination rate among newly born babies in Samoa fell from 74% in 2017 to 34% in 2018,^[22][23] similar to some of the poorest countries in Africa.^[9] Ideally, countries should have immunisation levels above 90%. Vaccination rates dropped to 31% in Samoa, compared to 99% in nearby Nauru, Niue, Cook Islands,^[15] and American Samoa.^[24]

In June 2019, American anti-vaccination activist Robert F. Kennedy Jr. visited Samoa to meet with local anti-vaccination activists including Taylor Winterstein and Edwin Tamanese, whom he called a "medical freedom hero". Kennedy also discussed vaccines with then-Prime Minister Tuilaʻepa Saʻilele Malielegaoi,^[25][26] and campaigned against the vaccine on social media.^[27][28]

After the measles outbreak started, anti-vaxxers (including Kennedy^[29]) credited the dozens of measles deaths to poverty and malnutrition or even to the vaccine itself, but there was no evidence for these claims, and clinicians reported that Vitamin A deficiency or immunodeficiency did not appear to be a substantial contributing factor to the outbreak.^[8]

In August 2019, an infected passenger on one of the more than 8,000 annual flights between New Zealand and Samoa probably brought the disease from Auckland to Upolu.^[8] A full outbreak began in October 2019 and continued for the next four months. Before seeking proper medical treatment, some parents first took their children to 'traditional healers' who used machines purchased from Australia that are claimed to produce immune-protective water.^[9] As of 22 December, there were 79 deaths (0.4 per 1,000, based on a population of 200,874,^[7][6] a rate of 14.3 deaths per 1000 infected) and 5,520 cases (2.75% of the population) of measles in Samoa.^[2][7][6] 61 out of the first 70 deaths were aged four and under and all but seven were aged under 15.^[30][31]

At least 20% of babies aged six to 11 months have contracted measles, and one in 150 babies have died.^[32]

As of 20 December 2019, 94% of the population had been vaccinated.^[32][33] 95% is required to acquire herd immunity for measles.^[32] Measles is much more contagious compared to other infectious diseases such as polio, which only requires an 80% vaccination rate for the population to attain herd immunity.^[34]

Initially, schools remained open after the outbreak was declared. The Samoan government initially did not accept humanitarian support.^[16]

A state of emergency was declared on 17 November, ordering the closure of all schools, keeping children under 17 away from public events, and making vaccination mandatory.^[35] UNICEF has sent 110,500 vaccines to Samoa. Tonga and Fiji have also declared states of emergency.^[36] Tonga closed all schools for several days, while American Samoa required all travelers from Tonga and Samoa to present proof of vaccination.^[37] In Fiji, vaccines were prioritised for young children and people travelling overseas.^[38]

In March 2019, the WHO and UN children's agency UNICEF warned the Pacific to take proactive measures and improve immunisation rates.^[39]

On 2 December 2019, the government imposed a curfew and cancelled all Christmas celebrations and public gatherings.^[40][41] All unvaccinated families were ordered to display a red flag or red cloth in front of their homes to warn others and to aid mass vaccination efforts.^[42] As part of aid efforts, the Royal New Zealand Air Force transported medical supplies and equipment to Samoa. Medical teams from New Zealand, Australia, the United Kingdom, France and its overseas territory of French Polynesia also assisted Samoan medical authorities.^[43]

On 5 and 6 December, the government shut down everything other than public utilities to assign all available civil servants to the vaccination campaign efforts.^[44]

Edwin Tamasese, an anti-vaccination activist with no medical training who is also the chair of a coconut farmers’ collective,^[8] was charged with "incitement against a government order".^[44] He had posted online comments like "Enjoy your killing spree."^[8] He encouraged people to refuse immunisation, as he believed the vaccine caused measles,^[45] and even discouraged life-saving antibiotics.^[8] Tamasese faced up to two years in prison.^[8]

The curfew was lifted on 7 December when the government estimated that 90% of the population had been reached by the vaccination program.^[46] Parliament passed a bill on 19 December to make measles vaccinations mandatory in 2020.^[47]

Nevertheless, as of 29 December, a public inquiry into the government's role in suspending vaccinations had not been announced. Deputy director of health Gaualofa Matalavea Saaga stated, "Having our case blasted out to the world is the last thing we want."^[8] Samoa's political opposition called for the health minister to be removed from his position.^[8]

On 31 December, Tuilaʻepa Saʻilele Malielegaoi, the Prime Minister of Samoa, addressed the nation to ring in the New Year; the measles outbreak was a focus of his speech. He acknowledged the support of the Samoan diaspora and 49 medical teams from the following countries and organisations: Australia, China, France/French Polynesia, Fiji through UNFPA, Israel, United States/Hawaii, Japan, Papua New Guinea, New Zealand, Norway, United Nations Agencies, United Kingdom and UK Save the Children, Solomon Islands and Kiribati through the Pacific Community, American Samoa, Médecins Sans Frontières, Blacktown Doctors Medical Centre, and Samoan Doctors Worldwide.^[48]

The low vaccination rate of Samoa came as a surprise to New Zealand's government.^[49] The Samoa Observer reported that New Zealand's Minister for Pacific People, William Sio, was "'of the impression' that Samoa had high immunisation rates. So to learn they were in fact fatality [sic] low was a shock."^[49]

Since the outbreak, several organisations and countries have responded:

• Australian Medical Assistance Teams (AUSMAT) sent a team of nurses, doctors, and public health experts as well as medical equipment and supplies to Samoa and left on 3 January 2020 after eight weeks in Samoa in one of its longest-ever missions.^[50][51]
• New Zealand sent three rotations of the New Zealand Medical Assistance Team (NZMAT) of doctors, nurses and logistics specialists who supported Leulumoega Hospital and Faleolo Clinic to the west of Apia for six weeks. NZ also sent a team of nurse vaccinators, 3,000 vaccination doses and vaccine fridges to Samoa in mid-November,^[52] and a small number of Intensive Care Clinicians. Residents of Rotorua, New Zealand sent two dozen infant-size coffins decorated with flowers and butterflies to Samoan families.^[53] On 14 December 2019, New Zealand Foreign Minister Winston Peters announced $1 million in funds towards preventive efforts in the Pacific.^[54]
• The United Kingdom EMT sent two rotations of doctors, nurses, physiotherapists, an anaesthetist, and an epidemiologist for four weeks of support from the end of November to December 2019.^[55]
• French Polynesia sent a team of paediatric nurses
• Israel sent Intensive Care teams to Samoa to help with relief efforts.^[56]
• Hawaii sent a medical mission of 75 doctors and nurses for two days at the beginning of December to assist with the mass vaccination campaign.
• On 10 December, American Samoa declared a measles outbreak and closed public schools and park gatherings^[57] and suspended all entry permits for those travelling through Samoa and Tonga to American Samoa.^[58]
• UNICEF has sent 200,000 vaccines to Samoa.^[36][59]
• The UN World Health Organization deployed 128 medical teams to assist in vaccination efforts. The UN Central Emergency Response Fund (CERF) allocated $2.7 million to support the response in Samoa as well as Tonga and Fiji.^[59]
• The World Bank gave a US$3.5 million grant to support the response to the outbreak and another US$9.3m grant over the next five years to improve the health system.^[56]
• Israel sent a team of two paediatricians, six nurses and one physiotherapist trained in disaster medicine from the Israel Center for Disaster Medicine and Humanitarian Response.^[60]

As of 24 December, the following agencies had sent Emergency Medical Team personnel to assist with the outbreak:^[61]

Tuilaepa said he would propose legislation that would penalise parents who refused to vaccinate their children.^[62] The Samoan government allocated US$2.5 million for relief work.^[62]

Immunology experts are now questioning the role of social media, primarily Facebook, and how social media facilitated the spread of vaccination hesitancy during the lethal outbreak. The Immunisation Advisory Centre in New Zealand sees the Samoan crisis as a sign that social media needs to deal with dangerous misinformation.^[63]

By 25 January 2020, Tuilaepa had resisted calls for an inquiry.^[64] Opposition MP Olo Fiti Vaʻai continued to call for an inquiry and was "apologising on behalf of Parliament and telling the people of Samoa that the government had failed miserably."^[65][16]

Following the ousting of the HRPP in the 2021 Samoan general election, new Health Minister Valasi Toogamaga Tafito announced he was considering establishing an inquiry into the epidemic.^[66]