Anti-white racism

Anti-white racism refers to discriminatory sentiments and acts of hostility of a racist nature toward people racialized as White (especially those people from Europe and its diasporas). It can manifest in various forms, including but not limited to ethnic hatred, stereotyping, exclusion, or violence, and can occur in both overt and subtle ways. These notions and the use of the term "anti-white racism" are an object of study in sociology, philosophy, political science and law, as well as a topic discussed in the media, by intellectuals and in the social sphere.

While anti-white racism is a topic of debate, it is often discussed in the context of systemic power dynamics, historical legacies of European colonialism, and contemporary social and political movements. The subject is contentious, with differing perspectives on its prevalence, impact, and comparison to other forms of racial discrimination. Examples of anti-white racism include attacks targetting white individuals and anti-white sentiments in post-apartheid South Africa and Zimbabwe, as well as in some parts of Europe and North America.

Concepts and study

[edit]

In philosophy

[edit]

According to Magali Bessone, professor of political philosophy at the Panthéon-Sorbonne University in Paris, if the phenomenon of racism is considered in a structural manner, then the notion of anti-white racism is not relevant "in societies where whites are in a position of domination. [Which] does not prevent the existence of individual behaviors that can be designated in this case as falling within the scope of racial hatred. And the definition of racism must probably be both individual and institutional."[1]

According to Jorge L. A. Garcia, philosophy professor at Boston College, anti-white racism is an "ugly phenomenon [...] damaging to the cause of racial justice."[2][3]

In social sciences

[edit]

Sociology studies racism by taking into account specific socio-historical contexts and the prior existence, in Western societies, of ideologies and policies that have historically given whites the role of the dominant race.[4][5][6] Researchers distinguish between what is racist behavior—rejection, anger, insults, aggression, etc.—of an individual nature, and the existence of systemic racism, i.e. racism that is embedded in the social organization.[7]

Pooja Sawrikar, a psychologist, and Ilan Katz, a social work researcher at the University of New South Wales, challenge this definition of racism, which they summarize as "Racism = Prejudice + Power". Finding this approach reductionist, they refute definitions of racism based on social power, which they believe reduce racism to white supremacy in white-majority societies. Thus, the idea that only white people can be racist would be flawed and itself racist. Furthermore, they assert that this approach, which places white people at the center of any discourse on race, leads to impotence in the fight against racism. This helplessness would manifest itself in a feeling of guilt among white people, due to the fact that they cannot do anything individually against racism since they are oppressors by virtue of their skin color, and a feeling of helplessness among ethnic minorities, who would be forced to admit that racism is a condition that they cannot change. This approach would also encourage passivity, both among white people not participating in the anti-racist struggle, who would be content with their assigned role as the dominant group, and among racial minorities, who would reject any responsibility because of their minority status.[8]

Close to this vision, the French political scientist, sociologist and historian Pierre-André Taguieff considers that the notions of institutional racism, structural racism or systemic racism derive from the anti-racist definition of racism produced by revolutionary African-American activists at the end of the 1960s. According to him, these terms are not the expression of a conceptualization of racism, but "a symbolic weapon which consists of reducing racism to white racism supposed to be inherent to 'white society' or to 'white domination', the latter being the only form of racial domination recognized and denounced by neo-antiracists." With white society being conceptualized as intrinsically racist, "it follows that anti-white racism cannot exist. This is a fundamental article of faith of the new 'anti-racist' catechism."[9]

Similarly, the French political scientist Laurent Bouvet considered that "racism is an anthropological phenomenon, both cultural and social, which affects all human societies. It is difficult to say in what way it is structural in any particular society, except when in some of them racist prejudices are established as a legal or institutional system — for example, in the Southern United States during segregation, or, of course, the apartheid regime in South Africa." and that "Racism exists everywhere, in all social groups, and is expressed, practically or theoretically, against the 'Other' on the basis of an identity linked to skin color or ethno-cultural origin." He criticized the "so-called anti-racist activists who claim that 'anti-white' racism does not exist" for doing so "from a purely political perspective to which, strangely given the very history of racism since the 19th century, certain researchers try to provide a basis that they want to be 'scientific'".[10]

For Daniel Sabbagh, research director at the Center for International Research (CERI) in Paris, racism can be understood from three points of view. The first is ideological racism, based on the hierarchy of races defined by a racialization of humanity. The second is attitudinal racism, the subject of studies in social psychology in particular, which conceives racism as a set of negative attitudes towards the racialized other. The third is systemic racism.[11] The researcher believes that the use of the expression "anti-White racism" is not abusive to characterize, for example, the ideological or attitudinal racism inevitably produced in reaction to the racism suffered, without common measure, by non-Whites. He cites as examples the ideological speech of Elijah Muhammad, leader of the Nation of Islam (NOI), likening whites to demons, and the video of the French rapper Nick Conrad, entitled "Pendez les Blancs" (Hang the Whites).[11] Daniel Sabbagh agrees that if we only consider systemic racism, as a conception of racism, then the expression "anti-white racism" is irrelevant. He believes, however, that racism must be studied in all its dimensions.[11]

In the media

[edit]

BBC News editor Mark Easton cites the Ross Parker murder case to argue that society has been forced to redefine racism and discard the definition of "prejudice plus power"—a definition which, in Easton's view, tends to only allow ethnic minorities to be victims and whites to be perpetrators. He states, "Describing an incident as racist may say as much about a victim's mindset as the offender. How else can one explain the British Crime Survey finding that 3,100 car thefts from Asians were deemed to be racially motivated?"[12] Journalist Yasmin Alibhai-Brown argues that the case highlights double standards of racial equality campaigners, suggesting black activists should "march and remember victims like Ross Parker ... our values are worthless unless all victims of these senseless deaths matter equally".[13] She writes, "to treat some victims as more worthy of condemnation than others is unforgivable and a betrayal of anti-racism itself".[14]

Following violent acts during French high school demonstrations on March 8, 2005, and their media coverage, journalist Luc Bronner's article in the newspaper Le Monde, entitled "High school student demonstrations: the specter of anti-white violence"[15] caused a media-political controversy in France over the labeling of this violence as "anti-white".[a][16][17] Following Luc Bronner's article, a number of personalities, particularly on the left, including Ghaleb Bencheikh, Alain Finkielkraut, Bernard Kouchner and Jacques Julliard, launched on March 25, 2005, an "Appeal against 'anti-White racial attacks'", initiated by the left-wing Zionist movement Hashomer Hatzair and the Jewish community radio station Radio Shalom.[16] A signatory of the appeal, Pierre-André Taguieff believes that the violence reveals the existence of anti-White racism in France, a reflection of a "racialization of social conflict" and that racism is not solely the work of Whites.[18] Despite the International League Against Racism and Anti-Semitism (LICRA) considering the racist nature of the attacks to be proven,[19] several anti-racist organizations, such as SOS Racisme, the MRAP and the Human Rights League (LDH), denounced the appeal as "irresponsible".[16][17]

By country

[edit]

France

[edit]
Anti-white graffito on a door in France. The text reads: "Here we are racists toward whites and not solidary".

Claims of racism against whites in France have been brought forward by various far-right parties,[20] and other groups beginning in the 1980s,[21] including from the right and left. In September 2012, Jean-François Copé, the leader of the Union for a Popular Movement (UMP), and then incumbent for his reelection, denounced the development of an anti-white prejudice by people living in France, some of them French citizens, against the "Gauls", a name among immigrants for the native French, according to him, on the basis of these having a different religion, color skin, and ethnic background.[22][23][24][25] The former Minister of the Interior, Claude Guéant, went on record stating that this kind of racism is a reality in France and that there is nothing worse than the political elite hiding from the truth.[22] When questioned on the subject, Prime Minister Jean-Marc Ayrault, a Socialist, acknowledged that such racism "can exist"; however, he indicated that one must be "very careful when using words of this nature", warning against "a kind of chase behind the ideas of the National Front".[26] His government's Minister of Women's Rights, Najat Vallaud-Belkacem, echoed this view when, in her book Raison de plus! (2012), she called on everyone to recognize the reality of such racism and to condemn it like all others.[17]

[edit]

French law does not categorize racist offenses according to the victim's ethnic origin; the judicial treatment of such offenses never includes the term "anti-white" in the qualification of the incriminating facts. However, the press sometimes uses the term when reporting on court cases involving racism against a white victim.[27][28] For example, in December 2012, the Criminal Court of Versailles sentenced an individual who had called his neighbor a "dirty white woman". Found guilty of "public insults of a racist nature", he was sentenced to a two-month suspended prison sentence with a two-year probation period.[29][28] In January 2014, a case of assault on a public road, during which insults such as "dirty white" or "dirty French" were uttered, went on trial. At the end of the trial, the Court of Appeal of Paris upheld the aggravating circumstance of "racism".[30][31] In March 2016, the Court of Appeal of Lyon increased the first instance sentence of an individual convicted of racial insults by three months in prison. The defendant had called a train passenger a "dirty white man, dirty Frenchman.".[32][33][34] Following the appeal judgment, Alain Jakubowicz, the president of the anti-racist association LICRA, declared that "all forms of racism are condemnable, wherever they come from and regardless of the victim's skin color, origin or religion. While anti-white racism is a relatively marginal phenomenon compared to other forms of racism or antisemitism, it must be subject to the same rigor and reprobation."[35][33]

In September 2018, French rapper Nick Conrad broadcast on the web a song and video called "Pendez les Blancs" (Hang the Whites), for which he was later prosecuted.[36][37][38] In particular, the judges found that "the terms of the song, accompanied by violent and brutal images, directly incite the Internet user to commit attacks on the lives of white people".[39]

Public opinion

[edit]

In a sociological survey conducted in 2008 by the French Institute for Demographic Studies (INED), which never uses the expression "anti-white racism", it appears that 16% of the majority population of France, i.e. the white population, say they have been the victim of a "racist situation", compared to 32% for immigrants and 36% for descendants of immigrants. 23% of the majority population say they "have not experienced a racist situation but feel exposed to it", compared to 29% for immigrants and 25% for descendants of immigrants. In addition, 10% of people of European origin say they have suffered racist discrimination in the last five years, compared to 26% for immigrants, 31% for descendants of two immigrant parents and 17% for descendants of one immigrant parent. The most reported grounds for discrimination by the majority population are 18% related to origin, compared to 70% for immigrants and 65% for descendants of immigrants.[40]

In 2012, INED published a new survey conducted between September 2008 and February 2009 on people born between 1948 and 1990, which showed that 18% of people belonging to the "majority population" said they had been "the target of racist insults, remarks or attitudes" compared to 30% for immigrants and 37% for descendants of immigrants.[41] However, a study by the same institute concluded in 2016 that the phenomenon was "not a mass experience": "Racism by minorities against majorities can be verbally offensive, or even physically aggressive, but it is not systematic and does not produce social inequalities."[42] The same year, Jean-Luc Primon, a sociologist at the University of Nice and researcher at the Migrations and Society Research Unit (URMIS), participating in the TEO survey, the first INED database on origins, declared that a little more than one person in ten of those classified in the so-called "majority" population (neither immigrants, nor from immigration, nor from overseas) declared having experienced racism.[43]

A 2022 survey found that 80% of French people believe that anti-white racism is present in some French communities.[44]

Haiti

[edit]
"Burning of the Plaine du Cap – Massacre of whites by the blacks." On 22 August 1791, slaves set fire to plantations, torched cities and massacred the white population.

The massacres of almost the entire white population in Haiti in 1804, also referred to as the Haitian genocide,[45][46][47] which marked the end of the Haitian Revolution,[48][49] have been partially explained in the context of anti-white racism.[50] On 22 February 1804, revolutionary leader Jean-Jacques Dessalines signed a decree ordering that all French people still residing in the country should be put to death.[51] Dessalines' secretary Louis Boisrond-Tonnerre complained that the declaration of independence was not aggressive enough, saying that "...we should have the skin of a white man for parchment, his skull for an inkwell, his blood for ink, and a bayonet for a pen!".[52]

The people chosen to be killed were targeted primarily based on three criteria: "skin color, citizenship and vocation." While some whites, such as Poles and Germans who were granted citizenship and "a few non-French veterans and American merchants, along with some useful professionals such as priests and doctors" were spared, political affiliation was not considered.[52] The white victims were almost entirely French, commensurate with their share in the white population of Haiti. About his targets of the massacre, Dessalines' slogan exemplified his mission to eradicate the white population with the saying "Break the eggs, take out the [sic] yoke [a pun on the word 'yellow' which means both yoke and mulatto] and eat the white."[52] Upper class whites were not the only target; any white of any socioeconomic status was also to be killed, including the urban poor known as petits blancs (little whites).[53] During the massacre, stabbing, beheading, and disemboweling were common.[54]

Historian Philippe R. Girard also states that if, after 1804 and throughout the 19th century, the presence of whites in the country was negligible, they were perceived, in particular by Haitian nationalists, with an antipathy that amounted to racism, excluding alliances with countries with generally white populations such as the United States and European countries, or considered too light-skinned, such as the Dominican Republic. The black population, a large majority (90% at the beginning of the 19th century), tended to consider themselves the only true Haitian population, calling themselves "authentic", with the exception of the mulattos, who were viewed with great suspicion because of their French fathers as well as their frequent possession of slaves before independence. The word blan, meaning "white man", came to designate the foreigner, and carried a negative connotation that that of neg, literally "negro", did not have.[55]

South Africa

[edit]

Democratic Alliance MP Gwen Ngwenya states that racism aimed at white people in South Africa is often overlooked compared to racism aimed at black people, noting that racism aimed at white people elicits little reaction from the populace.[56] According to a comparative study by the trade union Solidarity, South African media give more attention to white-on-black racism, and the South African Human Rights Commission is much more likely to self-initiate investigations into white-on-black racism and is more lenient in cases of black-on-white racism.[57]

The F.W. de Klerk Foundation reported that there are social media posts inciting extreme violence against white South Africans, and these posts come mostly from black South Africans. It appealed to the South African Human Rights Commission to intervene on the issue of racism and hate speech against white South Africans. Its complaint to the commission detailed "45 social media postings that incite extreme violence against White South Africans." The foundation also said "an analysis of Facebook and Twitter messages shows that by far the most virulent and dangerous racism – expressed in the most extreme and violent language – has come from disaffected Black South Africans. The messages are replete with threats to kill all whites – including children; to rape white women or to expel all whites from South Africa."[58]

After a black person was allegedly killed by two white people, businesses and properties owned by white people and other minorities in Coligny were targeted for destruction by members of the black community.[59][60]

Anti-white hate-speech

[edit]
On 12 September 2011, Julius Malema, the youth leader of South Africa's ruling ANC, was found guilty of hate speech for singing "Shoot the Boer" at a number of public events.[61]

A Gauteng government official, Velaphi Khumalo, stated on Facebook "White people in South Africa deserve to be hacked and killed like Jews. [You] have the same venom. Look at Palestine. [You] must be [burnt] alive and skinned and your [offspring] used as garden fertiliser".[62] A complaint was lodged at the Human Rights Commission, and a charge of crimen injuria was laid at the Equality Court. In October 2018, he was found guilty of hate speech by the court, for which he was ordered to issue an apology.[63]

In March 2018, a screenshot depicting EFF Ekurhuleni leader Mampuru Mampuru calling for racial violence on Facebook began to circulate on social media. The post read, "We need to unite as black People, there are less than 5 million whites in South Africa vs 45 million of us. We can kill all this white within two weeks. We have the army and the police. If those who are killing farmers can do it what are you waiting for. Shoot the boer, kill the farmer." [sic]. Mampuru claims the screenshot was fabricated in an attempt to discredit the EFF, further adding that "Without white people in the country‚ we are not going to have a Rainbow Nation."[64]

After 76-year-old white professor Cobus Naude was murdered in 2018, black senior SANDF officer Major M.V. Mohlala posted a comment on Facebook in reaction to Naude's murder, stating "It is your turn now, white people… [he] should have had his eyes and tongue cut out so that the faces of his attackers would be the last thing he sees".[65] Mohlala received a warning of potential future disciplinary action by the SANDF.[66] Subsequently, Ernst Roets of AfriForum contrasted Mohlala's punishment against that of convicted white racist Vicki Momberg, stating, "The inconsistency being applied in this country regarding minorities has reached the level of absurdity... The reality in South Africa is that a white person who insults a black person goes to prison, while a senior officer in the defence force who says white people's eyes and tongues must be stabbed out is simply asked nicely not to repeat it."[67]

A photograph emerged of a University of Cape Town student who wore a shirt that read "Kill All Whites" in a residence dining hall during early 2016.[68] The university later identified the wearer as Slovo Magida and reported the matter to SAPS and HRC.[69] During a parliamentary debate on racism, Pieter Mulder of the FF+ read out the contents of the shirt, to which some MPs shouted "Yes! Yes!".[70] As of 2018, no further action against Magida has been taken.

In April 2018, a Judicial Services Commission tribunal found that Nkola Motala's racist comments could justify his removal as a judge. Motala crashed into a wall while driving under the influence of alcohol in 2007. After the accident, Motala swore at a white onlooker, Richard Baird, and referred to him as a "boer".[71]

Julius Malema, leader of the third-largest party, Economic Freedom Fighters, stated at a political rally in 2016 that "we [the EFF] are not calling for the slaughter of white people‚ at least for now". When asked for comment by a news agency, the ANC spokesperson, Zizi Kodwa, stated that there would be no comment from the ANC, as "[h]e [Malema] was addressing his own party supporters." This received backlash from many South Africans of all races.[72] While still the ANCYL leader, Malema was taken to the Equality Court by AfriForum for repeatedly singing "dubul' ibhunu", which literally translates as "shoot the boer [white farmer]." In context, this was sung as a struggle (against apartheid) song. At another political rally in 2018, he stated, "Go after a white Man... We are cutting the throat of whiteness." This was in reference to the removal of Athol Trollip, a white mayor, from office in Port Elizabeth.[73] The opposition Democratic Alliance has accused the EFF leader of racism.[74]

At the EFF's 10th anniversary rally in 2023, Malema again sang the song to an estimated 90,000 supporters[75] at the FNB Stadium.[76] The incident received international coverage with Elon Musk criticizing Malema on Twitter for singing the song, accusing him of "openly pushing for the genocide of white people in South Africa".[76][77]

In September 2018, Black First Land First (BLF) Spokesperson Lyndsay Maasdorp told The Citizen reporter Daniel Friedman that, as a white person, his existence is "a crime". Maasdorp also posted on his now-suspended Twitter account in 2018: "I have aspirations to kill white people, and this must be achieved!".[78]

In December 2018, in response to comments made by Johann Rupert in support of the South African taxi industry, Mngxitama asserted at a BLF rally that "For each one person that is being killed by the taxi industry, we will kill five white people",[79] giving rise to the BLF slogan "1:5".[80] Mngxitama went on to say, "You kill one of us, we will kill five of you. We will kill their children, we will kill their women, we will kill anything that we find on our way."[81] The comments were criticized by many, including the African National Congress, with an ANC spokesperson claiming that "[Mngxitama's] comments clearly incite violence in South Africa" and urging the South African Human Rights Commission to investigate.[79] The Congress of the People and Democratic Alliance also criticized the statements and filed criminal charges against Mngxitama for incitement of violence. Mngxitama's Twitter account was also suspended as a result.[82] In response, the BLF’s deputy president, Zanele Lwana, responded that Mngxitama's comments were made in the context of self-defense and that "The only sin committed by BLF president is defending black people. President Mngxitama correctly stated that for every one black life taken, five whites would be taken!"[82]

In March 2022, the Equality Court of South Africa ordered BLF members Lindsay Maasdorp and Zwelakhe Dubasi to pay R200,000 in damages and make a public apology for "celebrat[ing] the tragic deaths"[83] of four children on social media in statements that were judged to be hate speech.[83] The four children, all of whom were white, died when a walkway collapsed at Hoërskool Driehoek in Vanderbijlpark.[83]

The Black First Land First party does not allow white people in the party.[84]

United Kingdom

[edit]

Racially motivated violence

[edit]

There have been incidents of violence in the United Kingdom where individuals have attacked white people due to hatred or as a form of racial retaliation. In 1994, Richard Norman Everitt, a 15-year-old white English teenager, was stabbed to death in London. Following ethnic tensions in his neighbourhood, Somers Town, Everitt was murdered by a gang of British Bangladeshis who were seeking revenge against another white boy. A judge described the killing as "an unprovoked racial attack".[85][86][87] In 2001, Ross Parker, a 17-year-old white English teenager was murdered in Peterborough, in what has been described as an unprovoked racially motivated crime. He bled to death after being stabbed, beaten with a hammer and repeatedly kicked by a gang of British Pakistani men.[88][89] The 2002 trial judge concluded that they had planned to find "a white male to attack simply because he was white" in the context of "hostility on the part of some of the younger white residents of the city against the Asian community".[90] In 2004, Kriss Donald, a 15-year-old white Scottish teenager was kidnapped, abused and murdered in Glasgow on the grounds of ethnicity. Four British Pakistani men were sentenced to life in prison for the crime, and admitted to choosing him because he was white.[91][92][93] In 2018, Ella Hill, a survivor of the Rotherham child sexual exploitation scandal, said she faced serious racial abuse by her attackers. Race was suggested as one of the factors involved in the failure to address the abuse.[94]

Public opinion

[edit]

In 2019, a British government inquiry by the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) into racism in universities found that 9% of white British students reported experiencing racial harassment, including anti-English, anti-Welsh and anti-Scottish sentiments (compared to 29% of black students, 27% of Asian students and 22% of other non-white or mixed race students). Academics of color have criticized the Commission for including harassment against white students in the statistics, which they say shows a worrying misunderstanding of racism as it "minimises the racism by including groups who do not experience racial prejudice".[95] Prominent academics and student leaders have criticized the Commission for "drawing a false equivalence between what it described as racial harassment against white British students and staff and the racism suffered by their black and minority ethnic peers". The EHRC did not respond to requests to remove anti-white harassment from the report, explaining that "its report made clear that racial harassment predominantly affects black and Asian students".[96]

United States

[edit]
The speeches of Elijah Muhammad (pictured left) and Louis Farrakhan (right), both leaders of the Nation of Islam (NOI), often emphasized hatred of whites.

There are black supremacists in the United States who advocate the superiority of the "black race", including organized groups such as the Nation of Islam (NOI) and the New Black Panther Party (NBPP). These groups have repeatedly been accused of stirring up racial hatred against whites.[97] The Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) classifies the NBPP as a black separatist hate group[98] and says that its leaders "have advocated the killing of Jews and white people",[99][100] while it describes the NOI as having a "theology of innate black superiority over whites".[101] The NOI was notably represented by Malcolm X and Khalid Abdul Muhammad, who made anti-white speeches and called for the murder of white Americans and white South Africans.[102][103][104] According to the NOI, whites were created 6,600 years ago as a "race of devils" by an evil scientist named Yakub,[105] a story which originated with the founder of the NOI, Wallace D. Fard.[101] The speeches of Elijah Muhammad and Louis Farrakhan, both leaders of the NOI, also often emphasized hatred of whites.[103][105] For example, at an event in Milwaukee in August 2015, Farrakhan said: "White people deserve to die, and they know, so they think it's us coming to do it".[106]

The United Nuwaubian Nation of Moors, a black supremacist group, founded and led by Dwight York,[107][108] has been described by the SPLC as advocating the belief that black people are superior to white people. The SPLC reported that York's teachings included the belief that "whites are 'devils', devoid of both heart and soul, their color the result of leprosy and genetic inferiority".[109][110] Another black supremacist group, the Nation of Yahweh, founded by Hulon Mitchell Jr., also known as Yahweh ben Yahweh, has been described by the SPLC as racist, stating that the group believes that Black people are the true Israelites and whites hold "wicked powers". The SPLC also claims that the group believes that Yahweh ben Yahweh had a Messianic mission to vanquish whites and that it held views similar to those of the Christian Identity movement, which believes that "Aryans" are the true Israelites and non-whites are devils. By 2007, the Nation of Yahweh had eliminated calls for violence and toned down its anti-white rhetoric, but remained Black supremacist and antisemitic in its ideology.[111]

Proponents of the pseudoscientific "melanin theory" argue that whites suffer from a melanin deficiency that makes them inferior to blacks in athletic, intellectual and spiritual terms.[112][113] According to Bernard Ortiz de Montellano, anthropology professor at Wayne State University in Detroit, this theory, which has been popular with some proponents of Afrocentrism and black supremacists, including professor of black studies Leonard Jeffries[114][115] and psychologist Frances Cress Welsing,[116][117] "reactivates biological racism."[112]

Public opinion

[edit]

A 2017 poll found that 55% of white Americans believe that white people face discrimination.[118] A 2022 poll found that 64% of Republicans polled said white people experience a fair amount of hate or discrimination in society.[119] A 2023 YouGov poll found that of Trump 2020 voters, 73% say that racism against white Americans is a problem.[120]

Zimbabwe

[edit]
Under Robert Mugabe's regime (pictured in 1979), discrimination and violence were perpetrated against the country's white community, with the participation and encouragement of the state.

Following the dissolution of Rhodesia and Zimbabwe's independence from British rule in 1980, the Zimbabwe African National Union–Patriotic Front (ZANU–PF) party came to power. At the time, most agricultural land was owned by white Zimbabweans.[121][122] The party, led by Robert Mugabe, implemented racist policies through land reform, confiscating land from whites and evicting them from their farms. Under President Robert Mugabe's regime, discrimination and violence were perpetrated against the country's white community, with the participation and encouragement of the state.[123][124][125][126] Most white farmers were dispossessed and several were murdered.[127][128][129] Mugabe was regularly accused of stoking hostility towards Zimbabwe's white farmers and blaming them for the failure of his land reform to save his power.[130][131][132] A racist ideology developed, with ZANU and ZAPU emphasizing the "sons and daughters of the soil" as genuine citizens as opposed to white aliens by nature (amabhunu).[133] On several occasions, Mugabe also made statements deemed racist towards whites,[126][134] referring to white Rhodesians as "blood-sucking exploiters", "sadistic killers", and "hard-core racists".[135] He called on supporters "to strike fear in the hearts of the white man, our real enemy",[136] and accused his black opponents of being dupes of the whites.[137] In one typical example, taken from a 1978 radio address, Mugabe declared: "Let us hammer [the white man] to defeat. Let us blow up his citadel. Let us give him no time to rest. Let us chase him in every corner. Let us rid our home of this settler vermin".[138]

Since then, Zimbabwe's white population has steadily declined, from 260,000 in 1975 to around 30,000 in 2014. While whites accounted for 80% of the national income, this agrarian policy has fostered famine in the former corn basket of Africa. From an exporter, the country became an importer.[132] In December 2008, the Southern African Development Community (SADC) Tribunal, in the case of Mike Campbell (Pvt) Ltd v Zimbabwe, accused Mugabe and his government of waging a racist political campaign in which land confiscations were carried out in a discriminatory manner.[139][140] The government and the Supreme Court of Zimbabwe contested the tribunal's decision.[141][140][142] However, in 2016, noting the harmful impact of his measures on agricultural production, Mugabe called for the return to the country of white farmers forced into exile.[143]

In 2017, new President Emmerson Mnangagwa's inaugural speech promised to pay compensation to the white farmers whose land was seized during the land reform program.[144] Rob Smart became the first white farmer whose land was returned after President Mnangagwa was sworn in to office; he returned to his farm in Manicaland province by military escort.[145] During the World Economic Forum 2018 in Davos, Mnangagwa also stated that his new government believes thinking about racial lines in farming and land ownership is "outdated", and should be a "philosophy of the past."[146]

Anti-white ethnic slurs

[edit]

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ This article mentioned the comments of young people from housing estates who claimed to have participated in the violence: "In the discourse of these young people, there were economic explanations ("making easy money"), playful explanations ("the pleasure of hitting") and a mixture of racism and social jealousy ("taking revenge on Whites")."[15]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Kodjo-Grandvaux, Séverine (13 October 2019). "Racisme : « La couleur demeure un marqueur de privilèges »" [Racism: "Color remains a marker of privilege"]. Le Monde (in French). Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  2. ^ Garcia 1999, p. 1–32.
  3. ^ Lentin 2018, p. 400–414.
  4. ^ Desmond, M. & Emirbayer, M. 2009, p. 335–355.
  5. ^ Ansell, A.E 2013, p. 75, 127, 129, 136.
  6. ^ Cashmore et al. 1996, p. 322.
  7. ^ Feagin 2006.
  8. ^ Sawrikar & Katz 2010.
  9. ^ Boucaud-Victoire, Kévin (25 October 2020). "Pierre-André Taguieff : "Ce pseudo-antiracisme rend la pensée raciale acceptable"" [Pierre-André Taguieff: "This pseudo-anti-racism makes racial thinking acceptable"]. www.marianne.net (in French). Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  10. ^ "Laurent Bouvet: «En parlant de "culture blanche", Lilian Thuram diffuse un discours essentialiste»". Le Figaro (in French). 6 September 2019. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  11. ^ a b c Sabbagh, Daniel (16 November 2020). "Le « racisme anti-Blancs » existe-t-il ?" [Does "anti-White racism" exist?]. Cogito (in French). Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  12. ^ Easton, Mark (8 November 2006). "Racism and race crime redefined". BBC News. London, UK: BBC. Retrieved 29 July 2011.
  13. ^ Alibhai-Brown, Yasmin (3 February 2003). "Brown/Black racism is every bit as bad as white racism". The Independent. London, UK: Independent Print Limited. Archived from the original on 31 January 2010. Retrieved 28 July 2011.
  14. ^ Alibhai Brown, Yasmin (26 October 2006). "When the victim is white, does anyone care?". London Evening Standard. ISSN 2041-4404.
  15. ^ a b "Manifestations de lycéens : le spectre des violences anti-"Blancs"" [High school demonstrations: the spectre of anti-"White" violence]. Le Monde (in French). 15 March 2005. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  16. ^ a b c "Un appel controversé contre le racisme "anti-blancs"" [A controversial appeal against “anti-white” racism]. Le Nouvel Obs (in French). 31 March 2005. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  17. ^ a b c "Une association réveille le débat sur le « racisme anti-Blanc »" [An association revives the debate on "anti-white racism"]. Le Point (in French). 2 February 2018. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  18. ^ "Un appel est lancé contre les "ratonnades anti-Blancs"". Le Monde (in French). 25 March 2005. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  19. ^ Licra, Appel contre "ratonnades anti-blancs" : polémique surprenante [Appeal against "anti-white racial attacks": surprising controversy] (in French), in AFP, 30 March 2005
  20. ^ Mestre, Abel; Monnot, Caroline (26 September 2012). "Comment l'extrême droite a fait du "racisme anti-blanc" une arme politique" [How the far right turned "anti-white racism" into a political weapon]. Le Monde (in French). Retrieved 16 January 2025.
  21. ^ Möschel 2014, p. 119.
  22. ^ a b "«Racisme anti-blanc» : Copé persiste et signe" ["Anti-white racism": Copé is sticking to his guns]. Libération (in French). 27 September 2012. Retrieved 16 January 2025.
  23. ^ Copé, Jean-François (26 September 2012). "Copé dénonce l'existence d'un «racisme anti-Blanc»" [Copé denounces the existence of "anti-White racism"]. Retrieved 16 January 2025.
  24. ^ "Les modérés de l'UMP avalent difficilement le pain au chocolat de Copé" [UMP moderates find Copé's pain au chocolat hard to swallow]. L'Express (in French). 8 October 2012. Retrieved 16 January 2025.
  25. ^ Bruno Roger-Petit, "Racisme anti-blanc" : comment Jean-François Copé nous a tendu un piège redoutable ["Anti-white racism": how Jean-François Copé set a terrible trap for us], Le Nouvel Obs, 26 September 2012
  26. ^ "Racisme anti-blanc: "ça peut exister", mais "je suis contre les communautarismes", indique Ayrault" [Anti-white racism: "it can exist", but "I'm against communitarianism", says Ayrault]. Le Point (in French). 27 September 2012. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  27. ^ "Racisme anti-blanc: Une «affaire symbolique» jugée à Paris" [Anti-white racism: A "symbolic case" goes to trial in Paris]. 20 Minutes (in French). 26 October 2012. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  28. ^ a b "Le racisme anti-Blanc en procès" [Anti-white racism on trial]. Le Point (in French). 26 October 2012. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  29. ^ "Deux mois avec sursis pour avoir traité sa voisine de «sale blanche»" [Two-month suspended sentence for calling his neighbor a "dirty white woman".]. Libération (in French). 17 December 2012. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  30. ^ "Première condamnation pour racisme « anti-Blanc »" [First conviction for "anti-white" racism]. Le Monde (in French). 22 January 2014. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  31. ^ "Le racisme anti-blanc, circonstance aggravante d'une agression à Paris" [Anti-white racism, an aggravating circumstance in a Paris assault]. leparisien.fr (in French). 22 January 2014. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  32. ^ Mag, Lyon (9 July 2015). "Rhône : un jeune condamné à Villefranche pour du racisme "anti-blanc"" [Rhône: young man sentenced in Villefranche for “anti-white” racism]. Lyon Mag (in French). Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  33. ^ a b "Trois mois ferme pour du racisme anti-blanc" [Three months in jail for anti-white racism]. Le Figaro (in French). 1 April 2016. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  34. ^ "Lyon - racisme anti-blanc. Condamnation alourdie par rapport à celle du tribunal de Villefranche". www.leprogres.fr (in French). 2 April 2016. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  35. ^ Mathiot, Cédric (27 September 2018). "Y a-t-il déjà eu des condamnations en France pour «racisme anti-blanc»?" [Have there ever been convictions in France for “anti-white racism”?]. Libération (in French). Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  36. ^ McAuley, James (27 September 2018). "A black French rapper sang about hanging 'the whites.' He may now be prosecuted". The Washington Post.
  37. ^ "Nick Conrad fait à nouveau polémique avec «Doux pays», la justice est saisie" [Nick Conrad creates a new controversy with "Doux pays", courts are called]. Le Parisien (in French). 19 May 2019. Retrieved 14 December 2021.
  38. ^ Laurent, Samuel (26 September 2018). "« Pendez les Blancs », itinéraire d'une indignation" ["Hang the Whites", diary of an uproar]. Le Monde (in French). Retrieved 14 December 2021.
  39. ^ "Avec son nouveau clip, le rappeur Nick Conrad provoque des réactions indignées" [With his new video, rapper Nick Conrad provokes outraged reactions]. L'Express (in French). 19 May 2019. Retrieved 18 February 2025.
  40. ^ Christelle Hamel, Expérience et perception des discriminations et du racisme (in French), in Trajectoires et Origines, Ined-Insee, 2008
  41. ^ Patrick Simon and Vincent Tiberj, Les immigrés et leurs descendants face à l'identité nationale (in French), in Les registres de l'identité, Work documents no. 176, Ined, 2012
  42. ^ "Trajectoires et origines". Ined - Institut national d’études démographiques (in French). Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  43. ^ Interview of Jean-Luc Primon by Sylvia Zappi (27 September 2012). ""Il y a une ethnicisation des rapports sociaux en France"" ["There is an ethnicization of social relations in France"]. Le Monde (in French). Retrieved 27 January 2025.
  44. ^ "D'après un sondage exclusif de l'institut CSA pour CNEWS, publié ce mercredi 5 octobre, 80% des Français interrogés pensent qu'un racisme anti-blanc existe en France, dans certaines communautés" ["According to an exclusive survey by the CSA institute for CNEWS, published this Wednesday, October 5, 80% of French people questioned think that anti-white racism exists in France, in certain communities."]. CNEWS. 5 October 2022.
  45. ^ Girard 2005a, p. 158–159.
  46. ^ Moses & Stone 2013, p. 63.
  47. ^ Forde 2020, p. 40.
  48. ^ Rogers 2010, p. 353.
  49. ^ Orizio 2001, p. 149, 157–159.
  50. ^ Girard 2005a, p. 138–161.
  51. ^ Blancpain 2003, p. 7.
  52. ^ a b c Girard 2005a.
  53. ^ Girard 2005a, p. 139.
  54. ^ Pezzullo 2006, p. 53.
  55. ^ Girard 2005b, p. 55–75.
  56. ^ Ngwenya, Gwen (7 January 2016). "'Racist' black South Africans who kept their jobs?". The Mail & Guardian. Retrieved 12 April 2017.
  57. ^ Brink, Eugene; Mulder, Connie (5 April 2017). "How the response to black and white racism differs – Solidarity". Politicsweb. Retrieved 12 April 2017.
  58. ^ "'Blacks more racist than whites' | IOL News". Retrieved 19 April 2018.
  59. ^ News24, Jeanette Chabalala. "'I don't own anything of my own' - Coligny woman who lost home in protests". News24. Retrieved 22 July 2021.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  60. ^ Malan, Rian. "Coligny: The shape of things to come?". News24. Retrieved 22 July 2021.
  61. ^ Staff reporters (11 September 2011). "ANC's youth leader found guilty of hate speech for Shoot the Boer song". The Guardian. Retrieved 11 September 2011.
  62. ^ "Khumalo in firing line over 'white genocide' | Cape Times". Retrieved 3 April 2018.
  63. ^ Makhafola, Getrude (5 October 2018). "ANALYSIS: Velaphi Khumalo found guilty of hate speech | Weekend Argus". IOL. African News Agency. Retrieved 2 July 2019.
  64. ^ "EFF councillor 'loves' his white friends and would never call for their genocide". Retrieved 10 April 2018.
  65. ^ "FF Plus gunning for SANDF Major, after racist rant – SA Breaking News". SA Breaking News. 30 March 2018. Retrieved 10 April 2018.
  66. ^ "SANDF fails to act against murderously anti-white major – Kobus Marais – POLITICS | Politicsweb". www.politicsweb.co.za. Retrieved 10 April 2018.
  67. ^ "Victory against racism | Saturday Star". Retrieved 10 April 2018.
  68. ^ "UCT: 'Kill all whites' T-shirt is hate speech". News24. Retrieved 11 April 2018.
  69. ^ "'Kill all whites' T-shirt culprit identified – UCT". News24. Retrieved 11 April 2018.
  70. ^ "'Kill all whites' drama in SA National Assembly". BusinessTech. Retrieved 11 April 2018.
  71. ^ "'Drunk judge' Motata faces impeachment over racism' lack of integrity". Retrieved 19 April 2018.
  72. ^ "Malema slammed for comments on whites". ENCA. 8 November 2016. Retrieved 30 May 2017.
  73. ^ "'We are cutting the throat of whiteness' – Malema on plans to remove Trollip". 4 March 2018. Retrieved 27 January 2025.
  74. ^ "South Africans don't share Malema's racist views – Maimane | IOL News". Retrieved 11 March 2018.
  75. ^ "South African opposition torn apart over apartheid song". Africanews. 1 August 2023. Retrieved 3 August 2023.
  76. ^ a b Kgosana, Rorisang (2 August 2023). "'I will sing 'Kill the Boer' as and when I please': Malema responds to struggle song outrage". TimesLIVE. Retrieved 3 August 2023.
  77. ^ Ditabo, Malaika (1 August 2023). "Elon Musk vs Julius Malema: EFF leader accused of inciting genocide with 'Kill the boer' song". News24. Retrieved 3 August 2023.
  78. ^ Friedman, Daniel. "White existence is a crime, says BLF spokesperson". The Citizen. Retrieved 19 September 2018.
  79. ^ a b Gous, Nico. "Mngxitama trying to take SA back to 'dark ages of apartheid' says ANC". SowetanLIVE. Sowetan Live. Retrieved 16 December 2018.
  80. ^ Friedman, Daniel (20 December 2018). "Mngxitama rejoins Twitter only to be banned within a day". The Citizen. Retrieved 13 January 2019.
  81. ^ Pijoos, Iavan (10 December 2018). "'You kill one black person, we kill five white people' – BLF president". Sunday Times. Retrieved 16 December 2018.
  82. ^ a b Nemakonde, Vhahangwele (11 December 2018). "Twitter suspends Mngxitama's account after 'kill whites' threats, IEC assessing what to do". The Citizen. Retrieved 16 December 2018.
  83. ^ a b c GroundUp, Tania Broughton for (7 March 2022). "GROUNDUP: Court orders Black First Land First to pay up for hate speech social media posts that vilified white people". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 10 March 2022.
  84. ^ BLF Back | Whites still not allowed in the party: Mngxitama, 5 February 2021, retrieved 23 May 2022
  85. ^ "At last, a fitting memorial for 15-year-old Richard Everitt". Camden New Journal. Retrieved 7 January 2025.
  86. ^ "Gang leader gets life for killing boy". The Independent. Archived from the original on 26 November 2024. Retrieved 7 January 2025.
  87. ^ Topping, Alexandra (30 September 2024). "'I need to own my narrative': man cleared of racist murder in 1995 on years of abuse". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 7 January 2025.
  88. ^ Morris, Steven (20 December 2002). "Three get life in jail for racist killing". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  89. ^ "Three guilty of teenager's murder". BBC News. 19 December 2002. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  90. ^ "R. v. Ahmed Ali Awan, [2008] EWHC 119 (QB)". Her Majesty's Court Service. 30 January 2008. Archived from the original on 18 February 2011. Retrieved 27 December 2011.
  91. ^ Carrell, Severin (9 November 2006). "Three jailed for life for race murder of schoolboy". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  92. ^ "Kriss attacked 'for being white'". BBC News. 5 October 2006. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  93. ^ "Abducted, stabbed and set on fire for being white". The Scotsman. 19 November 2004. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  94. ^ Hill, Ella (2018). "Voices. As a Rotherham grooming gang survivor". The Independent.
  95. ^ Batty, David (23 October 2019). "Universities failing to address thousands of racist incidents". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  96. ^ Batty, David (23 October 2019). "University racism study criticised for including anti-white harassment". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  97. ^ Barrett 2001, p. 253.
  98. ^ "New Black Panther Party". Southern Poverty Law Center. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  99. ^ Evans, Erica (24 July 2016). "Who are the New Black Panthers? '60s radicals say new group doesn't embody their ideals". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  100. ^ Desmond-Harris, Jenée (16 November 2014). "The New Black Panther Party, explained". Vox. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  101. ^ a b "Nation of Islam". Southern Poverty Law Center. Archived from the original on 11 October 2019. Retrieved 16 October 2019.
  102. ^ Gardell 1996, p. 264.
  103. ^ a b Anti-Defamation League, Adl Alerts Nation's Academic Leadership about Virus of Bigotry Being Spread by Khalid Abdul Muhammad, 1 July 1997
  104. ^ "Khalid Muhammad Dies at 53". The Washington Post. 18 February 2001. Retrieved 12 November 2017.
  105. ^ a b "Louis Farrakhan". Southern Poverty Law Center. Retrieved 20 February 2025.
  106. ^ "Farrakhan Promotes Million Man March with Anti-Semitism & Bigotry". Anti-Defamation League. 31 August 2015. Archived from the original on 25 March 2019. Retrieved 3 May 2019.
  107. ^ Palmer 2021a, p. 343–353.
  108. ^ Palmer 2021b, p. 694–723.
  109. ^ Bob Moser (20 September 2002). "United Nuwaubian Nation of Moors Meets Its Match in Georgia". Intelligence Report. Southern Poverty Law Center. Retrieved 12 January 2025.
  110. ^ "Nuwaubian Nation of Moors". Southern Poverty Law Center. Retrieved 5 March 2019.
  111. ^ "Miami-Based Nation of Yahweh Leader Appeals Parole". Southern Poverty Law Center. 16 January 2007. Retrieved 12 September 2018.
  112. ^ a b De Montellano 1993, p. 33–58.
  113. ^ Ferguson 2015, p. 67.
  114. ^ Morrow 2001, p. 19.
  115. ^ Ferguson 2015, p. 56.
  116. ^ Walker 2001, p. 80.
  117. ^ Newkirk 2002, p. 3.
  118. ^ Gonyea, Don (24 October 2017). "Majority Of White Americans Say They Believe Whites Face Discrimination". NPR. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  119. ^ "Poll: Most Republicans believe discrimination against whites is 'as big a problem' as anti-Black racism". Yahoo News. 30 May 2022. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  120. ^ Francis, Marquise; Romano, Andrew (21 July 2023). "Poll: Trump voters say racism against white Americans is a bigger problem than racism against Black Americans". Yahoo News. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  121. ^ Meredith 2002b, p. 120.
  122. ^ Mlambo 2014, p. 222–224, 254–256.
  123. ^ Blair 2002, p. 73; Meredith 2002b, p. 169.
  124. ^ "Fast Track Land Reform In Zimbabwe". Human Rights Watch. 8 March 2002. Retrieved 22 February 2025.
  125. ^ Heffer, Simon (12 August 2001). "We will not tolerate racism, except in Zimbabwe". The Telegraph. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  126. ^ a b Boisselet, Pierre. "Zimbabwe : Robert Mugabe, l'homme qui n'aimait pas les Blancs (et inversement)" [Zimbabwe: Robert Mugabe, the man who didn't like Whites (and vice versa)]. JeuneAfrique.com (in French). Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  127. ^ David McDermott Hughes (12 April 2010). Whiteness in Zimbabwe: Race, Landscape, and the Problem of Belonging. Springer. p. xiv. ISBN 978-0-230-10633-8. In 2000, paramilitaries killed their first white farmer in Virginia, Dave Stevens. More typically, armed groups surrounded farmhouses and harassed their occupants (meanwhile assaulting and often killing black farm workers).
  128. ^ Meredith 2002a, p. 171–175; Meredith 2002b, p. 167; Howard-Hassmann 2010, p. 899.
  129. ^ Gyldén, Axel (1 May 2007). "Le saigneur du Zimbabwe" [The blood lord of Zimbabwe]. L'Express (in French). Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  130. ^ Blair 2002, p. 42; Meredith 2002b, pp. 17, 128.
  131. ^ "Robert Mugabe refuses to give up". The Economist. ISSN 0013-0613. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  132. ^ a b Jean-Louis Tremblais, Zimbabwe, le naufrage d'Ubu roi [Zimbabwe, the sinking of King Ubu], in Le Figaro Magazine (in French), 24 November 2017, p. 26
  133. ^ Ndlovu-Gatsheni 2009a, p. 61–78; Ndlovu-Gatsheni 2009b, pp. 1151.
  134. ^ Ram, Etwareea (16 August 2001). "Le président Robert Mugabe rallume le racisme anti-Blancs au Zimbabwe" [President Robert Mugabe reignites anti-White racism in Zimbabwe]. Le Temps (in French). ISSN 1423-3967. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  135. ^ Blair 2002, p. 24.
  136. ^ Meredith 2002b, p. 17.
  137. ^ Meredith 2002b, p. 18.
  138. ^ Blair 2002, p. 11.
  139. ^ "Mike Campbell (Pvt) Ltd and Others v Republic of Zimbabwe (2/2007) [2008] SADCT 2 (28 November 2008)". www.saflii.org. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  140. ^ a b Fleming, Lucy (18 September 2008). "What's the lie of Zimbabwe's land?". BBC News. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  141. ^ "Zimbabwe vows to defy land ruling". BBC News. 1 December 2008. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  142. ^ Mike Campbell (Private) Limited v. The Minister of National Security Responsible for Land, Land Reform and Resettlement, Supreme Court of Zimbabwe, 22 January 2008
  143. ^ "Au Zimbabwe, les fermiers blancs prennent leur revanche sur Mugabe" [In Zimbabwe, white farmers take revenge on Mugabe]. Slate Afrique (in French). 15 February 2016. Retrieved 11 January 2025..
  144. ^ Oliphant, Roland; Thornycroft, Peta (24 November 2017). "President Emmerson Mnangagwa promises to pay compensation for land grabs and clean up Zimbabwe's 'poisoned politics' as he is sworn in". The Telegraph. ISSN 0307-1235. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  145. ^ Mutsaka, Farai (28 January 2018). "First white farmer gets land back under Zimbabwe's new leader". The Independent. Retrieved 11 January 2025.
  146. ^ Mnangagwa on land: 'We don't think along racial lines... it's outdated' News24. 26 January 2018

Bibliography

[edit]
[edit]