Glasgow University Dialectic Society

This article relies excessively on references to primary sources. Please improve this article by adding secondary or tertiary sources. Find sources: "Glasgow University Dialectic Society" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2011) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

Glasgow University Dialectic Society

Formation	1451
Location	Glasgow
Membership	~145 (excl. Life Members)
President	Lucy Hindmarsh [1]
Honorary Secretary	Colson Merrill[1]
Honorary President	Humza Yousaf
Colours
Parent organization	University of Glasgow
Affiliations	Glasgow University Union, Students' Representative Council, Queen Margaret Union, Clinton Foundation
Website	Society Website

The Glasgow University Dialectic Society, re-instituted in 1861, is a student society at the University of Glasgow, Scotland, committed to the promotion of debating, logic, ethics and literary discussion at the university. The society is independent and open to all students of the university, but maintains strong links with debating at Glasgow University Union.

The date of the society's foundation is contested; the earliest paper records of the society are dated before 1770, and there are, moreover, mentions within the university records of a society existing and being open to students who took Logic, back when the university still resided within Glasgow Cathedral. Pope John Paul II issued a 'Papal Letter' to the society upon his visit to Scotland in 1982, which recognised the society's claim to have been established in 1451. The society was formally re-instituted in 1861. The society has led the UK's university debating culture since 1953. In 1955, it won the Observer Mace, now the John Smith Memorial Mace, named after the deceased GUU debater and former leader of the British Labour Party. The Society won the 1983 World University Debating Championships in Princeton with a team headed by John Nicolson and Frank McKiergan.^[2] The GUU has since won the Mace debating championship sixteen more times, far more than any other university. The GUU has also won the World Universities Debating Championships five times.

The society organises a variety of events during term-time ranging from panel debates and discussions to social mixers and show debates for its members. In November, the society holds a New Members' Dinner, followed in March by the Annual Members' Dinner, held shortly before the AGM. Additionally it holds the Honorary President's Debate and a Sports Day - the Dialectic Olympics - as part of its marquee annual events. The society holds a number of more informal events, especially during Freshers' Week, to attract new members.

Two internal competitions are organised by the society: the Reftable, for new speakers; and the Garry-MacDonald Debate, between incoming and outgoing club leaders of the Glasgow University Union's Parliamentary Clubs.

The Dialectic Society, along with the Glasgow University Medico-Chirurgical Society and Glasgow University Athletic Club, was one of the founding societies of the Glasgow University Union in 1885, as well as being instrumental in establishing the Glasgow University Students' Representative Council the following year, and remains an active contributor to the activities of both organisations.^[3]

The archives of Glasgow University Dialectic Society are maintained by the Archives of the University of Glasgow (GUAS).

The management of the society is entrusted to a board elected at the Annual General Meeting (AGM). The Board consists of an Executive of five individuals comprising the President, Vice-President, Honorary Secretary, Honorary Treasurer, and Assistant Honorary Secretary. They are additionally joined on the Board by the Whip Secretary, Publicity Secretary, Macer, Social convenor, Welfare Officer, Charity Officer, Archive Librarian, and up to four Ordinary Board Members, the number of which is determined by the newly elected Executive.^[1] Two first-year members are elected to the Board by the end of the first semester of each year. The Convenor of Debates of the Glasgow University Union and the Society's immediate past President are Ex Officio members of the Board.

The 2024-2025 Board is:

Executive

• President - Lucy Hindmarsh
• Vice President - Alyssa Mills
• Honorary Secretary - Harry Smith
• Honorary Treasurer - Sally Dean
• Assistant Honorary Secretary - Eva Sjolund-Hosking

Non-Executive

• Whip Secretary - Cameron MacKenzie
• Publicity Secretary - Martin Mullaney
• Macer - Amy Simmons
• Social Convenor - Colson Merill
• Welfare Officer - Natasha Cameron
• Charity Officer - Anoushka Ross
• Archives Librarian - Morven Connell
• Ordinary Board Member - Ian Tam
• Ordinary Board Member - Zoe McFadyen

Ex Officio

• Past President - Emma Walker
• GUU Convenor of Debates - George Comstock

The electoral procedure at the AGM runs such that posts are filled in descending order, allowing those who failed to win more important posts to stand for others. The AGM was traditionally held at the end of the university's Candlemas Term, around the middle of March. Despite the new semester-based structure of the university's academic year, this remains the case and the AGM is now held shortly before the end of the teaching period of the second semester, which is separated from the exam period by the Easter vacation.

At the AGM the Society elects an Honorary President, alongside up to eight Honorary Vice-Presidents and Honorary Life Members. Those elected are often respected public figures and persons who have done some service to the Society, although less serious joke candidates often also make it onto the ballot. ^[4] From time to time these elections have generated some public controversy, most notably with the previous choices of Bobby Sands and Leopoldo Galtieri.^[5][6] The current Honorary President is current First Minister Humza Yousaf.

One of the honorary president's duties is to chair the Honorary President's Debate, held in February each year. If not chaired by the Honorary President, then the next highest ranking member of the Board (usually the President) will chair the debate.

Notable former members of the society include:

• Sir Menzies Campbell — former leader of the Liberal Democrats^[7]
• Donald Dewar — former First Minister of Scotland
• Liam Fox — Secretary of State for International Trade
• Brian Gill, Lord Gill — Lord Justice Clerk
• Derry Irvine, Lord Irvine — former Lord Chancellor
• Charles Kennedy — former leader of the Liberal Democrats, former Rector of the University
• Andrew Neil — journalist and broadcaster
• Meta Ramsay — former Secret Intelligence Service officer
• John Smith — former leader of the Labour Party, President 1960-1961^[8][9]
• Paul Sweeney — Labour & Co-operative MSP for Glasgow Region
• Cosmo Gordon Lang, Baron Lang — former Archbishop of Canterbury^[10]

Groundings

Discipline	Humanities, arts, social sciences
Language	English
Publication details
History	2007–present
Publisher	Glasgow University Union (United Kingdom)
Frequency	Annually
Open access	Yes
License	CC-BY 4.0
Standard abbreviations ISO 4 (alt) · Bluebook (alt) NLM (alt) · MathSciNet (alt )
ISO 4	Groundings
Indexing CODEN (alt · alt2) · JSTOR (alt) · LCCN (alt) MIAR · NLM (alt) · Scopus
ISSN	1754-7474 (print) 1755-2702 (web)
Links
Journal homepage Current Issue

The society was responsible for the founding of Groundings, an interdisciplinary journal publishing work in the humanities, arts, and social sciences.^[11]

Groundings was established by the society in 2007 and has since been published annually. The purpose of the journal is to provide an opportunity for undergraduate students at the university to have their work peer-reviewed and published in an accessible academic resource as a stepping stone to publication in more mainstream scholarly journals. As such, all entries are written by undergraduate students, and the editorial board is made up of undergraduates, although there exists an advisory panel mainly comprising academics of the university drawn from a range of disciplines.

Following an agreement between the Society and the Glasgow University Union in 2018, control over the management and publication of Groundings was transferred into the remit of the Convener of Libraries on the Board of Management of the Glasgow University Union, with the archives librarian acting as a representative for the Dialectic Society amongst the editors.

There are generally around ten articles per volume, each written and peer-reviewed by undergraduate students, and each volume of the journal follows a theme, to which it is intended the articles in that volume will relate. The theme for the first volume was "Identity and Commemoration", and for the second volume, "Individuals, institutions, and the relations between them". The themes used are intentionally broad in order to accommodate the largest variety possible between submissions, whilst ensuring each volume retains a sense of inherent direction.

The journal is produced in paper and electronic form, with initial funding for publication provided by the Chancellor's Fund. Print copies are made available to a number of depositories in the United Kingdom, including the Glasgow University Library, and the journal is available to read online.

• Records of Glasgow University Dialectic Society
• Glasgow University Dialectic Society