| Date | Winning League (All-Time Record) | Score | Venue | Host Team | Attendance | MVP | Winning Pitcher | Losing Pitcher |
| July 6, 1933 | American
(1–0–0 AL) | 4–2 | Comiskey Park | Chicago White Sox | 47,595 | | Lefty Gomez, New York (AL) | Bill Hallahan, St. Louis (NL) |
| July 10, 1934 | American
(2–0–0 AL) | 9–7 | Polo Grounds | New York Giants | 48,368 | | Mel Harder, Cleveland (AL) | Van Mungo, Brooklyn (NL) |
| July 8, 1935 | American
(3–0–0 AL) | 4–1 | Cleveland Stadium | Cleveland Indians | 69,812 | | Lefty Gomez, New York (AL) | Bill Walker, St. Louis (NL) |
| July 7, 1936 | National
(3–1–0 AL) | 4–3 | National League Park | Boston Bees | 25,556 | | Dizzy Dean, St. Louis (NL) | Lefty Grove, Boston, (AL) |
| July 7, 1937 | American
(4–1–0 AL) | 8–3 | Griffith Stadium | Washington Senators | 31,391 | | Lefty Gomez, New York (AL) | Dizzy Dean, St. Louis (NL) |
| July 6, 1938 | National
(4–2–0 AL) | 4–1 | Crosley Field | Cincinnati Reds | 27,067 | | Johnny Vander Meer, Cincinnati (NL) | Lefty Gomez, New York (AL) |
| July 11, 1939 | American
(5–2–0 AL) | 3–1 | Yankee Stadium | New York Yankees | 62,892 | | Tommy Bridges, Detroit (AL) | Bill Lee, Chicago (NL) |
| July 9, 1940 | National
(5–3–0 AL) | 4–0 | Sportsman's Park | St. Louis Cardinals | 32,373 | | Paul Derringer, Cincinnati (NL) | Red Ruffing, New York (AL) |
| July 8, 1941 | American
(6–3–0 AL) | 7–5 | Briggs Stadium | Detroit Tigers | 54,674 | | Eddie Smith, Chicago (AL) | Claude Passeau, Chicago (NL) |
| July 6, 1942 | American
(7–3–0 AL) | 3–1 | Polo Grounds | New York Giants | 34,178 | | Spud Chandler, New York (AL) | Mort Cooper, St. Louis (NL) |
| July 13, 1943 | American
(8–3–0 AL) | 5–3 | Shibe Park | Philadelphia Athletics | 31,938 | | Dutch Leonard, Washington (AL) | Mort Cooper, St. Louis (NL) |
| July 11, 1944 | National
(8–4–0 AL) | 7–1 | Forbes Field | Pittsburgh Pirates | 29,589 | | Ken Raffensberger, Philadelphia (NL) | Tex Hughson, Boston (AL) |
| July 10, 1945 | Game canceled due to World War II-related travel restrictions.
Game was originally scheduled to be held at Fenway Park in Boston, Massachusetts. |
| July 9, 1946 | American
(9–4–0 AL) | 12–0 | Fenway Park | Boston Red Sox | 34,906 | | Bob Feller, Cleveland (AL) | Claude Passeau, Chicago (NL) |
| July 8, 1947 | American
(10–4–0 AL) | 2–1 | Wrigley Field | Chicago Cubs | 41,123 | | Spec Shea, New York (AL) | Johnny Sain, Boston (NL) |
| July 13, 1948 | American
(11–4–0 AL) | 5–2 | Sportsman's Park | St. Louis Browns | 34,009 | | Vic Raschi, New York (AL) | Johnny Schmitz, Chicago (NL) |
| July 12, 1949 | American
(12–4–0 AL) | 11–7 | Ebbets Field | Brooklyn Dodgers | 32,577 | | Virgil Trucks, Detroit (AL) | Don Newcombe, Brooklyn (NL) |
| July 11, 1950 | National
(12–5–0 AL) | 4–3
(14) | Comiskey Park | Chicago White Sox | 46,127 | | Ewell Blackwell, Cincinnati (NL) | Ted Gray, Detroit (AL) |
| July 10, 1951 | National
(12–6–0 AL) | 8–3 | Briggs Stadium | Detroit Tigers | 52,075 | | Sal Maglie, New York (NL) | Ed Lopat, New York (AL) |
| July 8, 1952 | National
(12–7–0 AL) | 3–2
(5) | Shibe Park | Philadelphia Phillies | 32,785 | | Bob Rush, Chicago (NL) | Bob Lemon, Cleveland (AL) |
| July 14, 1953 | National
(12–8–0 AL) | 5–1 | Crosley Field | Cincinnati Reds | 30,846 | | Warren Spahn, Milwaukee (NL) | Allie Reynolds, New York (AL) |
| July 13, 1954 | American
(13–8–0 AL) | 11–9 | Cleveland Stadium | Cleveland Indians | 69,751 | | Dean Stone, Washington (AL) | Gene Conley, Milwaukee (NL) |
| July 12, 1955 | National
(13–9–0 AL) | 6–5
(12) | County Stadium | Milwaukee Braves | 45,643 | | Gene Conley, Milwaukee (NL) | Frank Sullivan, Boston (AL) |
| July 10, 1956 | National
(13–10–0 AL) | 7–3 | Griffith Stadium | Washington Senators | 28,843 | | Bob Friend, Pittsburgh (NL) | Billy Pierce, Chicago (AL) |
| July 9, 1957 | American
(14–10–0 AL) | 6–5 | Busch Stadium | St. Louis Cardinals | 30,693 | | Jim Bunning, Detroit (AL) | Curt Simmons, Philadelphia (NL) |
| July 8, 1958 | American
(15–10–0 AL) | 4–3 | Memorial Stadium | Baltimore Orioles | 48,829 | | Early Wynn, Chicago (AL) | Bob Friend, Pittsburgh (NL) |
| July 7, 1959 | National
(15–11–0 AL) | 5–4 | Forbes Field | Pittsburgh Pirates | 35,277 | | Johnny Antonelli, San Francisco (NL) | Whitey Ford, New York (AL) |
| August 3, 1959 | American
(16–11–0 AL) | 5–3 | Memorial Coliseum | Los Angeles Dodgers | 55,105 | | Jerry Walker, Baltimore (AL) | Don Drysdale, Los Angeles (NL) |
| July 11, 1960 | National
(16–12–0 AL) | 5–3 | Municipal Stadium | Kansas City Athletics | 30,619 | | Bob Friend, Pittsburgh (NL) | Bill Monbouquette, Boston (AL) |
| July 13, 1960 | National
(16–13–0 AL) | 6–0 | Yankee Stadium | New York Yankees | 38,362 | | Vern Law, Pittsburgh (NL) | Whitey Ford, New York (AL) |
| July 11, 1961 | National
(16–14–0 AL) | 5–4
(10) | Candlestick Park | San Francisco Giants | 44,115 | | Stu Miller, San Francisco (NL) | Hoyt Wilhelm, Baltimore (AL) |
| July 31, 1961 | TIE
(16–14–1 AL) | 1–1 | Fenway Park | Boston Red Sox | 31,851 | N/A |
| July 10, 1962 | National
(16–15–1 AL) | 3–1 | D.C. Stadium | Washington Senators | 45,480 | Maury Wills, Los Angeles (NL) | Juan Marichal, San Francisco (NL) | Camilo Pascual, Minnesota (AL) |
| July 30, 1962 | American
(17–15–1 AL) | 9–4 | Wrigley Field | Chicago Cubs | 38,359 | Leon Wagner, Los Angeles (AL) | Ray Herbert, Chicago (AL) | Art Mahaffey, Philadelphia (NL) |
| July 9, 1963 | National
(17–16–1 AL) | 5–3 | Cleveland Stadium | Cleveland Indians | 44,160 | Willie Mays, San Francisco (NL) | Larry Jackson, Chicago (NL) | Jim Bunning, Detroit (AL) |
| July 7, 1964 | National
(17–17–1) | 7–4 | Shea Stadium | New York Mets | 50,850 | Johnny Callison, Philadelphia (NL) | Juan Marichal, San Francisco (NL) | Dick Radatz, Boston (AL) |
| July 13, 1965 | National
(18–17–1 NL) | 6–5 | Metropolitan Stadium | Minnesota Twins | 46,706 | Juan Marichal, San Francisco (NL) | Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles (NL) | Sam McDowell, Cleveland (AL) |
| July 12, 1966 | National
(19–17–1 NL) | 2–1
(10) | Busch Memorial Stadium | St. Louis Cardinals | 49,936 | Brooks Robinson, Baltimore (AL) | Gaylord Perry, San Francisco (NL) | Pete Richert, Washington (AL) |
| July 11, 1967 | National
(20–17–1 NL) | 2–1
(15) | Anaheim Stadium | California Angels | 46,309 | Tony Pérez, Cincinnati Reds (NL) | Don Drysdale, Los Angeles (NL) | Catfish Hunter, Kansas City (AL) |
| July 9, 1968 | National
(21–17–1 NL) | 1–0 | Astrodome | Houston Astros | 48,321 | Willie Mays, San Francisco (NL) | Don Drysdale, Los Angeles (NL) | Luis Tiant, Cleveland (AL) |
| July 23, 1969 | National
(22–17–1 NL) | 9–3 | RFK Stadium | Washington Senators | 45,259 | Willie McCovey, San Francisco (NL) | Steve Carlton, St. Louis (NL) | Mel Stottlemyre, New York (AL) |
| July 14, 1970 | National
(23–17–1 NL) | 5–4
(12) | Riverfront Stadium | Cincinnati Reds | 51,838 | Carl Yastrzemski, Boston (AL) | Claude Osteen, Los Angeles (NL) | Clyde Wright, California Angels (AL) |
| July 13, 1971 | American
(23–18–1 NL) | 6–4 | Tiger Stadium | Detroit Tigers | 53,559 | Frank Robinson, Baltimore (AL) | Vida Blue, Oakland (AL) | Dock Ellis, Pittsburgh (NL) |
| July 25, 1972 | National
(24–18–1 NL) | 4–3
(10) | Atlanta Stadium | Atlanta Braves | 53,107 | Joe Morgan, Cincinnati (NL) | Tug McGraw, New York (NL) | Dave McNally, Baltimore (AL) |
| July 24, 1973 | National
(25–18–1 NL) | 7–1 | Royals Stadium | Kansas City Royals | 40,849 | Bobby Bonds, San Francisco (NL) | Rick Wise, St. Louis (NL) | Bert Blyleven, Minnesota (AL) |
| July 23, 1974 | National
(26–18–1 NL) | 7–2 | Three Rivers Stadium | Pittsburgh Pirates | 50,706 | Steve Garvey, Los Angeles (NL) | Ken Brett, Pittsburgh (NL) | Luis Tiant, Boston (AL) |
| July 15, 1975 | National
(27–18–1 NL) | 6–3 | County Stadium | Milwaukee Brewers | 51,480 | Bill Madlock, Chicago (NL)
Jon Matlack, New York (NL) | Jon Matlack, New York (NL) | Catfish Hunter, New York (AL) |
| July 13, 1976 | National
(28–18–1 NL) | 7–1 | Veterans Stadium | Philadelphia Phillies | 63,974 | George Foster, Cincinnati (NL) | Randy Jones, San Diego (NL) | Mark Fidrych, Detroit (AL) |
| July 19, 1977 | National
(29–18–1 NL) | 7–5 | Yankee Stadium | New York Yankees | 56,683 | Don Sutton, Los Angeles (NL) | Don Sutton, Los Angeles (NL) | Jim Palmer, Baltimore (AL) |
| July 11, 1978 | National
(30–18–1 NL) | 7–3 | San Diego Stadium | San Diego Padres | 51,549 | Steve Garvey, Los Angeles (NL) | Bruce Sutter, Chicago (NL) | Rich Gossage, New York (AL) |
| July 17, 1979 | National
(31–18–1 NL) | 7–6 | Kingdome | Seattle Mariners | 58,905 | Dave Parker, Pittsburgh (NL) | Bruce Sutter, Chicago (NL) | Jim Kern, Texas (AL) |
| July 8, 1980 | National
(32–18–1 NL) | 4–2 | Dodger Stadium | Los Angeles Dodgers | 56,088 | Ken Griffey, Sr., Cincinnati (NL) | Jerry Reuss, Los Angeles (NL) | Tommy John, New York (AL) |
| August 9, 1981 | National
(33–18–1 NL) | 5–4 | Cleveland Stadium | Cleveland Indians | 72,086 | Gary Carter, Montreal (NL) | Vida Blue, San Francisco (NL) | Rollie Fingers, Milwaukee (AL) |
| July 13, 1982 | National
(34–18–1 NL) | 4–1 | Olympic Stadium | Montreal Expos | 59,057 | Dave Concepción, Cincinnati (NL) | Steve Rogers, Montreal (NL) | Dennis Eckersley, Boston (AL) |
| July 6, 1983 | American
(34–19–1 NL) | 13–3 | Comiskey Park | Chicago White Sox | 43,801 | Fred Lynn, California (AL) | Dave Stieb, Toronto (AL) | Mario Soto, Cincinnati (NL) |
| July 10, 1984 | National
(35–19–1 NL) | 3–1 | Candlestick Park | San Francisco Giants | 57,756 | Gary Carter, Montreal (NL) | Charlie Lea, Montreal (NL) | Dave Stieb, Toronto (AL) |
| July 16, 1985 | National
(36–19–1 NL) | 6–1 | Hubert H. Humphrey Metrodome | Minnesota Twins | 54,960 | LaMarr Hoyt, San Diego (NL) | LaMarr Hoyt, San Diego (NL) | Jack Morris, Detroit (AL) |
| July 15, 1986 | American
(36–20–1 NL) | 3–2 | Astrodome | Houston Astros | 45,774 | Roger Clemens, Boston (AL) | Roger Clemens, Boston (AL) | Dwight Gooden, New York (NL) |
| July 14, 1987 | National
(37–20–1 NL) | 2–0
(13) | Oakland–Alameda County Coliseum | Oakland Athletics | 49,671 | Tim Raines, Montreal (NL) | Lee Smith, Chicago (NL) | Jay Howell, Oakland (AL) |
| July 12, 1988 | American
(37–21–1 NL) | 2–1 | Riverfront Stadium | Cincinnati Reds | 55,837 | Terry Steinbach, Oakland (AL) | Frank Viola, Minnesota (AL) | Dwight Gooden, New York (NL) |
| July 11, 1989 | American
(37–22–1 NL) | 5–3 | Anaheim Stadium | California Angels | 64,036 | Bo Jackson, Kansas City (AL) | Nolan Ryan, Texas (AL) | John Smoltz, Atlanta (NL) |
| July 10, 1990 | American
(37–23–1 NL) | 2–0 | Wrigley Field | Chicago Cubs | 39,071 | Julio Franco, Texas (AL) | Bret Saberhagen, Kansas City (AL) | Jeff Brantley, San Francisco (NL) |
| July 9, 1991 | American
(37–24–1 NL) | 4–2 | SkyDome | Toronto Blue Jays | 52,383 | Cal Ripken Jr., Baltimore (AL) | Jimmy Key, Toronto (AL) | Dennis Martínez, Montreal (NL) |
| July 14, 1992 | American
(37–25–1 NL) | 13–6 | Jack Murphy Stadium | San Diego Padres | 59,372 | Ken Griffey Jr., Seattle (AL) | Kevin Brown, Texas (AL) | Tom Glavine, Atlanta (NL) |
| July 13, 1993 | American
(37–26–1 NL) | 9–3 | Oriole Park at Camden Yards | Baltimore Orioles | 48,147 | Kirby Puckett, Minnesota (AL) | Jack McDowell, Chicago (AL) | John Burkett, San Francisco (NL) |
| July 12, 1994 | National
(38–26–1 NL) | 8–7
(10) | Three Rivers Stadium | Pittsburgh Pirates | 59,568 | Fred McGriff, Atlanta (NL) | Doug Jones, Philadelphia (NL) | Jason Bere, Chicago (AL) |
| July 11, 1995 | National
(39–26–1 NL) | 3–2 | The Ballpark in Arlington | Texas Rangers | 50,920 | Jeff Conine, Florida (NL) | Heathcliff Slocumb, Philadelphia (NL) | Steve Ontiveros, Oakland (AL) |
| July 9, 1996 | National
(40–26–1 NL) | 6–0 | Veterans Stadium | Philadelphia Phillies | 62,670 | Mike Piazza, Los Angeles (NL) | John Smoltz, Atlanta (NL) | Charles Nagy, Cleveland (AL) |
| July 8, 1997 | American
(40–27–1 NL) | 3–1 | Jacobs Field | Cleveland Indians | 44,916 | Sandy Alomar Jr., Cleveland (AL) | José Rosado, Kansas City (AL) | Shawn Estes, San Francisco (NL) |
| July 7, 1998 | American
(40–28–1 NL) | 13–8 | Coors Field | Colorado Rockies | 51,267 | Roberto Alomar, Baltimore (AL) | Bartolo Colón, Cleveland (AL) | Ugueth Urbina, Montreal (NL) |
| July 13, 1999 | American
(40–29–1 NL) | 4–1 | Fenway Park | Boston Red Sox | 34,187 | Pedro Martínez, Boston (AL) | Pedro Martínez, Boston (AL) | Curt Schilling, Philadelphia (NL) |
| July 11, 2000 | American
(40–30–1 NL) | 6–3 | Turner Field | Atlanta Braves | 51,323 | Derek Jeter, New York (AL) | James Baldwin, Chicago (AL) | Al Leiter, New York (NL) |
| July 10, 2001 | American
(40–31–1 NL) | 4–1 | Safeco Field | Seattle Mariners | 47,364 | Cal Ripken Jr., Baltimore (AL) | Freddy García, Seattle (AL) | Chan Ho Park, Los Angeles (NL) |
| July 9, 2002 | TIE
(40–31–2 NL) | 7–7
(11) | Miller Park | Milwaukee Brewers | 41,871 | N/A |
| July 15, 2003 | American
(40–32–2 NL) | 7–6 | U.S. Cellular Field | Chicago White Sox | 47,609 | Garret Anderson, Anaheim (AL) | Brendan Donnelly, Anaheim (AL) | Éric Gagné, Los Angeles (NL) |
| July 13, 2004 | American
(40–33–2 NL) | 9–4 | Minute Maid Park | Houston Astros | 41,886 | Alfonso Soriano, Texas (AL) | Mark Mulder, Oakland (AL) | Roger Clemens, Houston (NL) |
| July 12, 2005 | American
(40–34–2 NL) | 7–5 | Comerica Park | Detroit Tigers | 41,617 | Miguel Tejada, Baltimore (AL) | Mark Buehrle, Chicago (AL) | John Smoltz, Atlanta (NL) |
| July 11, 2006 | American
(40–35–2 NL) | 3–2 | PNC Park | Pittsburgh Pirates | 38,904 | Michael Young, Texas (AL) | B. J. Ryan, Toronto (AL) | Trevor Hoffman, San Diego (NL) |
| July 10, 2007 | American
(40–36–2 NL) | 5–4 | AT&T Park | San Francisco Giants | 43,965 | Ichiro Suzuki, Seattle (AL) | Josh Beckett, Boston (AL) | Chris Young, San Diego (NL) |
| July 15, 2008 | American
(40–37–2 NL) | 4–3
(15) | Yankee Stadium | New York Yankees | 55,632 | J. D. Drew, Boston (AL) | Scott Kazmir, Tampa Bay (AL) | Brad Lidge, Philadelphia (NL) |
| July 14, 2009 | American
(40–38–2 NL) | 4–3 | Busch Stadium | St. Louis Cardinals | 46,760 | Carl Crawford, Tampa Bay (AL) | Jonathan Papelbon, Boston (AL) | Heath Bell, San Diego (NL) |
| July 13, 2010 | National
(41–38–2 NL) | 3–1 | Angel Stadium of Anaheim | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | 45,408 | Brian McCann, Atlanta (NL) | Matt Capps, Washington (NL) | Phil Hughes, New York (AL) |
| July 12, 2011 | National
(42–38–2 NL) | 5–1 | Chase Field | Arizona Diamondbacks | 49,033 | Prince Fielder, Milwaukee (NL) | Tyler Clippard, Washington (NL) | C. J. Wilson, Texas (AL) |
| July 10, 2012 | National
(43–38–2 NL) | 8–0 | Kauffman Stadium | Kansas City Royals | 40,933 | Melky Cabrera, San Francisco (NL) | Matt Cain, San Francisco (NL) | Justin Verlander, Detroit (AL) |
| July 16, 2013 | American
(43–39–2 NL) | 3–0 | Citi Field | New York Mets | 45,186 | Mariano Rivera, New York (AL) | Chris Sale, Chicago (AL) | Patrick Corbin, Arizona (NL) |
| July 15, 2014 | American
(43–40–2 NL) | 5–3 | Target Field | Minnesota Twins | 41,048 | Mike Trout, Los Angeles (AL) | Max Scherzer, Detroit (AL) | Pat Neshek, St. Louis (NL) |
| July 14, 2015 | American
(43–41–2 NL) | 6–3 | Great American Ball Park | Cincinnati Reds | 43,656 | Mike Trout, Los Angeles (AL) | David Price, Detroit (AL) | Clayton Kershaw, Los Angeles (NL) |
| July 12, 2016 | American
(43–42–2 NL) | 4–2 | Petco Park | San Diego Padres | 42,386 | Eric Hosmer, Kansas City (AL) | Corey Kluber, Cleveland (AL) | Johnny Cueto, San Francisco (NL) |
| July 11, 2017 | American
(43–43–2) | 2–1
(10) | Marlins Park | Miami Marlins | 37,188 | Robinson Canó, Seattle (AL) | Craig Kimbrel, Boston (AL) | Wade Davis, Chicago (NL) |
| July 17, 2018 | American
(44–43–2 AL) | 8–6
(10) | Nationals Park | Washington Nationals | 43,843 | Alex Bregman, Houston (AL) | Edwin Diaz, Seattle (AL) | Ross Stripling, Los Angeles (NL) |
| July 9, 2019 | American
(45–43–2 AL) | 4–3 | Progressive Field | Cleveland Indians | 36,747 | Shane Bieber, Cleveland (AL) | Masahiro Tanaka, New York (AL) | Clayton Kershaw, Los Angeles (NL) |
| July 14, 2020 | Game canceled due to a delay in the start of the 2020 season as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Game was originally scheduled to be held at Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles, California. |
| July 13, 2021 | American
(46–43–2 AL) | 5–2 | Coors Field | Colorado Rockies | 49,184 | Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Toronto (AL) | Shohei Ohtani, Los Angeles (AL) | Corbin Burnes, Milwaukee (NL) |
| July 19, 2022 | American
(47–43–2 AL) | 3–2 | Dodger Stadium | Los Angeles Dodgers | 52,518 | Giancarlo Stanton, New York (AL) | Framber Valdez, Houston (AL) | Tony Gonsolin, Los Angeles (NL) |
| July 11, 2023 | National
(47–44–2 AL) | 3–2 | T-Mobile Park | Seattle Mariners | 47,159 | Elías Díaz, Colorado (NL) | Camilo Doval, San Francisco (NL) | Félix Bautista, Baltimore (AL) |
| July 16, 2024 | American
(48–44–2 AL) | 5–3 | Globe Life Field | Texas Rangers | 39,343 | Jarren Duran, Boston (AL) | Mason Miller, Oakland (AL) | Hunter Greene, Cincinnati (NL) |
| July 15, 2025 | | | Truist Park | Atlanta Braves | | | | |
| July 2026 | | | Citizens Bank Park | Philadelphia Phillies | | | | |
French
Deutsch