Monumento a los Constructores

Monumento a los Constructores
The monument in 2016
Map
Location
ArtistJosé Luis Padilla Retana
Year1995 (1995)
MediumBronze
Weight8 t (7.9 long tons; 8.8 short tons)
ConditionPartly destroyed
LocationMorelia
Coordinates19°41′48.4″N 101°10′06.6″W / 19.696778°N 101.168500°W / 19.696778; -101.168500

The Monumento a los Constructores (lit. transl. Builders Monument), also known as the Monumento a los Constructores de la Ciudad (lit. transl. Builders of the City Monument), is a partly-destroyed outdoor bronze monument installed along Acueducto Avenue, in the historic center of Morelia, Michoacán, Mexico. The artwork was created by José Luis Padilla Retana and was unveiled in May 1995 in honor of those who built the city.

The monument depicted four men, a New Spain master builder and Fray Antonio de San Miguel [es] behind two Purépecha men, one carving a stone and the other carrying a carved block on his back. By 2020, the Supreme Indigenous Council of Michoacán (CSIM) began petitioning for the removal of the monument citing that they considered it a racist monument that portrayed the slave-owning submission of indigenous people. However, they failed to reach a consensus with the city government; in February 2022, multiple CSIM members toppled two of the statues.

Members of the CSIM will seek to replace the remainder of the monument with a statue of Tangaxuan II, the last ruler of the Purépecha State.[1]

Description and meaning

[edit]

The Monumento a los Constructores is a 1.5 m (4 ft 11 in) long artwork that formerly featured four statues and weighed 8 t (7.9 long tons; 8.8 short tons).[2] From near to far, the first statue features a Purépecha mason who carries a stone on his back. He is dressed in torn clothes and bare-chested.[3] The next statue shows a Purépecha man carving a squared stone. Then, shoulder to shoulder, there were the statues of a master builder holding a blueprint and Fray Antonio de San Miguel [es] who had his left arm outstretched. According to the plaque, the mason was selected to represent the anonymous builders, the stonemason for his knowledge of cutting stone, the master builder represented the architects and engineers, and Fray Antonio symbolized the ecclesiastical and civil governments, as well as all those who influenced the erection of the city.[4] Fray Antonio, bishop of the diocese of Michoacán, was chosen as he ordered the construction of the city's aqueduct [es] during a time of drought in 1785.[5] He was in favor of the liberties of the native peoples and of civil equality between the population.[3]

The main message of the plaque reads in Spanish in all caps (translated to English):

To the builders of the city
The inhabitants of the city of Morelia erect, full of gratitude and pride, this monument dedicated to the memory of the builders of Guayangareo-Valladolid-Morelia. Monumental and beautiful city, warp of stone and culture, which we have inherited, and to which his illustrious son, José Ma. Morelos, called it "The Garden of New Spain".
Xavier Tavera Alfaro, chronicler of the city. 21 May 1995.[a]

José Luis Padilla Retana was the designer. He explained that the mason carries the stone on his back, not as a punishment but as a way of transporting the blocks and then carrying them up to a higher place. He also commented that Fray Antonio did not point to give an order but he pointed to the distance to a neutral point of the aqueduct.[6] The monument is located at the starting point of the aqueduct on a vegetal slope that symbolizes the Loma de Guayangareo, where the city was built.[4] The city was later renamed to Valladolid and later to Morelia.[7]

History

[edit]
The monument along Acueducto Avenue

The creation of the monument started in 1993[6] and was supervised by a board of trustees chaired by José Antonio Romo, a local photographic chronicler. It was installed as a means of appreciation to those who built in the 1700s the historic center of Morelia, in the state of Michoacán.[4] It was installed on 18 May 1995,[6] and the government of the state unveiled it three days later.[8] The monument was never registered as municipal, state or national heritage.[2][9]

By 2020, members of the Supreme Indigenous Council of Michoacán (Spanish: Consejo Supremo Indígena de Michoacán; CSIM), which is integrated by 60 indigenous communities in the state,[10] requested to the local government the removal of the monument, citing their disagreement with it, and labeled it as racist, a symbol of slavery and submission, and a reminder of the Spanish conquest of the Purépecha State, which they termed as a genocide.[11] The CSIM also argued that the monument recalled centuries of exploitation and trivialized how the architects and priests treated the Indigenous populations.[3] According to the historian Eduardo Rubio Elosúa, there is no evidence of slavery involved in the construction of the aqueduct.[12]

On 12 October 2020 (Columbus Day or Day of the Pluricultural Nation, as it is locally known), a demonstration took place next to the monument and damaged it minimally.[13] The city's cultural heritage body said about the requested removal: "You just have to read the simple and clear plaque on the monument to feel pride in our city, the birthplace of great thinkers".[14] On 1 August 2021, members of the council held a referendum in the state to determine whether or not the monument had to be removed. Of the ten tables installed, 905 people voted: 810 in favor and 87 against. Of those votes, 259 came from inhabitants of Morelia: 172 in favor and 87 against. The government did not qualify it as a binding consultation because it only represented 0.03% of the city's population.[15] On 11 October 2021, members of the council threatened to topple the monument the following day. Instead, they covered the sculptures with a blue tarpaulin.[16]

Toppling

[edit]

On 14 February 2022, members of the council toppled the sculptures of Fray Antonio and the master builder, with the former being beheaded.[14] In this regard, the CSIM published a bulletin informing that "[g]iven the indolence, racism, discrimination and lack of attention by the Morelia City Council [...] we decided collectively in a General Assembly of Authorities, to remove on our own account the so-called sculpture 'The Builders', for being a symbol of subordination, representation of slavery and an emblem of the Spanish genocide".[b] The damage amounted to 800,000 pesos (US$37,000) according to the State Attorney General's Office, while the city estimated it at 200,000 pesos (US$9,700).[18] The event took place on the 492nd anniversary of the execution of Tangaxuan II, the last ruler of the Purépecha State, by Nuño de Guzmán, a Spanish conquistador.[19] The police arrested 24 people in various locations, 21 of whom were adults who agreed to repair the damage caused; the remaining three were minors who were referred to the corresponding court.[20] During the same night, and as a protest, demonstrators stole three vehicles and set them on fire on Mexican Federal Highway 14.[20] By 28 February, the defendants challenged the agreement because they considered that their rights had been violated by being arrested outside the area where the events occurred, by being exposed by the media during the protest and by being physically assaulted during their arrests, and at the same time they notified that they would legally proceed against those who arrested them.[18]

Prior to its toppling, Padilla Retana said: "In the time of Francisco Antonio de San Miguel there was a great famine, he was a source of work for multiple indigenous people who came from various places. This sculpture had no major complication, I represented what I was asked for, I imagined the scene according to the historical elements. It represents the mason, the stonemason, those who direct the work. I don't understand why they are surprised that someone is naked and another with clothes, that's how the work was in those times and even nowadays. It's not about hurting anyone or offending anyone, it's about highlighting the human sacrifice, the effort".[c] After its partial destruction, Padilla Retana commented that the monument was not intended to "humiliate anyone, nor denigrate our roots" and offered to rebuild it but mentioned that there are no molds of the original sculptures.[22]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ A los constructores de la ciudad
    Los habitantes de la ciudad de Morelia erigen, llenos de gratitud y orgullo, este monumento dedicado a la memoria de los constructores de Guayangareo-Valladolid-Morelia. Monumental y hermosa urbe, urdimbre de piedra y cultura, que hemos heredado, y a las que su preclaro hijo, José Ma. Morelos, la llamara "El Jardín de la Nueva España".
    Xavier Tavera Alfaro, cronísta de la ciudad. 21 de mayo de 1995    .[4]
  2. ^ Original text in Spanish: "Ante la indolencia, racismo, discriminación y falta de atención por parte del Ayuntamiento de Morelia (...) decidimos colectivamente en una Asamblea General de Autoridades, retirar por nuestra propia cuenta la denominada escultura 'Los Constructores', por ser un símbolo de subordinación, representación del esclavismo y un emblema del genocidio español".[17]
  3. ^ Original text in Spanish: "En la época de Francisco Antonio de San Miguel hubo una hambruna muy grande, él fue una fuente de trabajo para muchos indígenas que venían de varios lados. Esta escultura no tuvo mayor complicación, representé lo que me pidieron, la escena la imaginé así de acuerdo a los elementos históricos. Se representa al tameme, al cantero, a los que dirigen la obra. No entiendo porqué se sorprenden de que alguien esté desnudo y otro con ropa, así era el trabajo en aquellos tiempos y aún hoy. No se trata de lastimar a nadie ni de ofender a nadie, se trata de resaltar el sacrificio humano, el esfuerzo".[21]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ "Habrá nuevo monumento en Morelia en lugar de Los Constructores" [There will be a new monument in Morelia in the place of The Builders]. Mi Morelia (in Spanish). 14 February 2023. Retrieved 18 June 2023.
  2. ^ a b García, Omaida (13 October 2021). "Removerá Morelia monumento Los Constructores" [Morelia will remove Builders monument]. El Sol de Morelia (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 23 February 2022. Retrieved 22 February 2022.
  3. ^ a b c Guillén, Beatriz (15 February 2022). "Guerra contra las estatuas en México: decapitada la escultura de un fraile español en Morelia" [War against statues in Mexico: sculpture of a Spanish friar in Morelia beheaded]. El País (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 17 February 2022. Retrieved 17 February 2022.
  4. ^ a b c d Orozco, Carolina (10 October 2020). "A 25 años de su creación, la escultura de Los Constructores, es un símbolo de gratitud y orgullo" [25 years after its creation, the Builders sculpture, is a symbol of gratitude and pride]. Mural Morelia (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 17 February 2022. Retrieved 17 February 2022.
  5. ^ Estrada, Jocelyn (15 February 2022). "Indígenas derriban y decapitan estatua de Fray Antonio de San Miguel en Morelia" [Indigenous people demolish and decapitate statue of Fray Antonio de San Miguel in Morelia]. Milenio. Morelia. Archived from the original on 17 February 2022. Retrieved 17 February 2022.
  6. ^ a b c Manzo, Jorge (20 February 2022). "'Mi obra no ofende', señala creador de escultura Los Constructores, destruida en Morelia" ['My work does not offend', says creator of sculpture Los Constructores, destroyed in Morelia]. La Voz de Michoacán (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 1 March 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  7. ^ Martínez Baracs, Rodrigo (1991). "Mehuacan, Guayangareo, Valladolid: los orígenes de Morelia" (PDF). Los orígenes de Morelia: Guyangareo-Valladolid (in Spanish). Archived (PDF) from the original on 1 August 2020. Retrieved 17 February 2022 – via National Institute of Anthropology and History.
  8. ^ Salgado, Fernando (14 February 2022). "Consejo Supremo Indígena derriba parte del 'Monumento a los Constructores'" [Supreme Indigenous Council topples part of the 'Builders Monument']. Post Data (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 17 February 2022. Retrieved 17 February 2022.
  9. ^ Martínez Elorriaga, Ernesto (17 February 2022). "Detenciones arbitrarias tras derribo de escultura en Morelia: Consejo Indígena" [Arbitrary arrests after demolition of sculpture in Morelia: Indigenous Council]. La Jornada (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 1 March 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  10. ^ Martínez Elorriaga, Ernesto (11 October 2021). "Indígenas michoacanos exigirán respeto a su autonomía el 12 de octubre" [Indigenous people from Michoacán will demand respect for their autonomy on 12 October]. La Jornada (in Spanish). Morelia. Archived from the original on 23 February 2022. Retrieved 22 February 2022.
  11. ^ Martínez Elorriaga, Ernesto (24 September 2021). "Purépechas exigen retiro de monumento por considerarlo racista" [Purépechas demand removal of monument because they consider it racist]. La Jornada (in Spanish). Morelia. Archived from the original on 23 February 2022. Retrieved 22 February 2022.
  12. ^ "'Por moda' desvirtúan significado de 'Los Constructores': Eduardo Rubio" [For "trendy reasons" they distort the meaning of "Los Constructores": Eduardo Rubio]. Mi Morelia (in Spanish). Morelia. 11 October 2020. Archived from the original on 1 March 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  13. ^ Jiménez, Héctor (12 October 2020). "El 'Monumento a Los Constructores' se mantiene en pie, también la intención de consulta para quitarlo o dejarlo" [The 'Builders Monument' is still standing, also the intention of consultation to remove or leave it]. La Voz de Michoacán (in Spanish). Morelia. Archived from the original on 28 February 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  14. ^ a b "Mexico's Indigenous Purepecha knock down statues of Spanish colonial-era priest". NBC News. Associated Press. 15 February 2022. Archived from the original on 28 February 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  15. ^ García, Omaida (3 August 2021). "Exige Consejo Supremo remover monumento Los Constructores" [Supreme Indigenous Council of Michoacán demands the removal of the Builders Monument]. El Sol de Morelia (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 28 February 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  16. ^ Mendoza, Angélica (12 October 2021). "Protestan en monumento Los Constructores por Día de la Raza" [Protests at the Builders Monument on Día de la Raza]. El Sol de Morelia (in Spanish). Retrieved 28 February 2022.[permanent dead link‍]
  17. ^ "AMLO 'abrió la herida' por Conquista española; mexicanos derriban estatuas de la época" [AMLO 'opened the wound' for Spanish Conquest; Mexicans topple statues of the era]. Alto Nivel (in Spanish). EFE. 16 February 2022. Archived from the original on 28 February 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  18. ^ a b Mendoza, Paola (28 February 2022). "Analizan denunciar a policías por detenciones tras demolición de Los Constructores" [Police officers to be sued for arrests after toppling of Builders Monument]. El Sol de Zamora (in Spanish). Morelia. Archived from the original on 28 February 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  19. ^ Hernández, Alejandra (14 February 2022). "Derriban monumento a Constructores en avenida Acueducto de Morelia" [Builders Monument toppled on Acueducto Avenue in Morelia]. CB Televisión (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 28 February 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  20. ^ a b Estrada, Arturo (15 February 2022). "Indígenas purépechas derriban estatua del español Fray Antonio de San Miguel en Morelia" [Purépecha indigenous people demolish statue of the Spaniard Fray Antonio de San Miguel in Morelia]. El Financiero (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 1 March 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  21. ^ Caroma, Caliche (25 September 2020). "¿Derrumbar o resignificar?" [To demolish or to resignify?]. El Artefacto (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 1 March 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
  22. ^ Manzo, Jorge (24 February 2022). ""Los Constructores" la escultura de la discordia" ["The Builders" the sculpture of discord]. La Voz de Michoacán (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 1 March 2022. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Monumento_a_los_Constructores&oldid=1259257357"