Venus Verticordia

Venus Verticordia ("Changer of Hearts"^[1] or "Heart-Turner"^[2]) was an aspect of the Roman goddess Venus conceived as having the power to convert either virgins or sexually active women from dissolute desire (libido)^[3] to sexual virtue (pudicitia).^[4] Under this title, Venus was especially cultivated by married women, and on 1 April she was celebrated at the Veneralia festival^[5] with public bathing.

The epithet Verticordia derives from the Latin words verto, "turn", and cor, the heart as "the seat of subjective experience and wisdom".^[2] The conversion, however, was thought of as occurring in the mind – the mens or "ethical core".^[2] Women were thus viewed as having the moral agency necessary for shaping society, albeit in roles differing from men.^[2]

Venus Verticordia was one of several goddesses whose new or reinterpreted theology or cult practice was meant to inform the conduct of women as a response to wartime upheaval and social crisis during the Roman Republic. The "turning" or conversion of Venus Verticordia was not meant to suppress sexual desire but to encourage its positive expression in marriage, a purposing of its power for social benefit^[6] in a display of personal excellence.^[7]

The first Roman shrine (aedes) for any form of Venus had been built during the Third Samnite War in 295 BC.^[8] Located near the racetrack of the Circus Maximus and dedicated to Venus Obsequens ("Compliant" Venus),^[9] it was funded by fines imposed by the aediles on upper-class married women charged with sexual misconduct (stuprum).^[10] During the wars of the Middle Republic that expanded Rome's presence throughout the Mediterranean world, and especially during the Punic Wars (264–146 BC), social and economic power among Roman women of the propertied classes increased, as they stepped in to manage domestic matters in the absence of men deployed at war. At the same time, anxieties about untethered women led to regulation of their behaviors in relation to men through both legislation and religious cultivation, counterbalancing their contributions to the Roman state and relative autonomy on the home front with expectations of loyalty and self-discipline expressed sexually.^[11]

The cult of Venus Verticordia^[a] was established with the installation of a statue (simulacrum^[13]) around the time of the Second Punic War,^[14] before 204 BC,^[15] possibly 220^[2] or 214 BC,^[16] or as early as 237 or 224 BC.^[17][b] A note in Pliny the Elder that the statue was dedicated before the importation of the Mother of the Gods in 204 BC establishes a terminus ad quem.^[18] A commission of ten men (decemviri) was appointed by the senate to consult with the Sibylline Books,^[19] but no ancient source specifies a precipitating event.^[20] Schilling thought it likely that the statue was dedicated after the founding of Venus Erycina's temple in 217 BC,^[18] whose "unwholesome influences" as a goddess of sexual commerce Verticordia may have been meant to counterbalance.^[21] A date of 215/214 BC might suggest that expiation was sought after the conviction and deaths of two Vestals who broke their vows around that time, following the disastrous Battle of Cannae the year before.^[22][23]

The official process behind the dedication was similar to the establishing of other women-centered cults such as that of Fortuna Muliebris at the beginning of the 5th century BC or the religious reparations owed to Juno Regina in 207 BC.^[24] A list was compiled of one hundred matronae – respectable married women – eligible to make the dedication, then their number was narrowed to ten by sortition (drawing lots). The ten women themselves nominated a Sulpicia, wife of a consul,^[17] as the most worthy of the honor among them.^[15][25] Pliny implies that it was the first time a woman was selected for a religious task on behalf of the state in this way,^[26] and says that this process was followed again in the selection of Claudia Quinta as the leading matron when the Magna Mater was brought to Rome in 204 BC.^[27]

The initial location of the founding statue is uncertain – generally, in the Vallis Murcia, between the northern slope of the Minor Aventine and the farther end of the Circus Maximus.^[28] It was possibly dedicated in the shrine of either Venus Obsequens or Erycina,^[25] or it may have been placed in an open-air precinct (templum) where Verticordia's shrine (aedes^[29]) was erected about a hundred years later.^[30]

The Temple of Venus Verticordia was one of several established by the Roman Republic in response to perceived outbreaks of female debauchery, in this instance incestum, the violation of religious chastity by three of the six women serving as "professionally chaste" Vestals.^[31][32][33] By the end of the 2nd century BC, overall Rome was on sound military footing, but a few defeats, one major,^[34] signaled instability and external threats to Rome's security, which the order of the Vestals was meant to embody.^[35] The Sibylline books were again consulted, and Verticordia's became the last of eight temples – dedicated to ten different deities, seven of them goddesses – that the Romans built in accordance with Sibylline authority.^[36] The earlier cult statue of Verticordia would have been moved there.^[25]

Work on the temple started in 114 BC. It was located in the Vallis Murcia,^[38] possibly near the shrine of Murcia at the Circus Maximus, but the proximity of functionally overlapping temples to Murcia and multiple Venuses in this area leaves uncertainties in interpreting the ancient texts.^[39][40] Coarelli assumed that the Temple of Venus Verticordia physically replaced that of the archaic Fortuna Virilis; the two deities shared a feast day. No traces of these buildings have been detected in the archaeological record at the site.^[41] Other than the annual feast day when the statue was bathed, nothing is known of the shrine's quotidian operations; since Verticordia was cultivated only by women, it seems likely that temple personnel included priestesses and female attendants.^[42]

Denarius (46 BC) perhaps depicting Venus Verticordia on the reverse, with the Dioscuri on the obverse^[c]

Woodcut reconstructing details (Dictionary of Roman Coins, 1889)

Since an identification by numismatists in the 19th century,^[43][44] a Republican denarius issued in 46 BC has sometimes been thought to depict Venus Verticordia on the reverse. The diademed figure holds a balance scale in her right hand and a sceptre in the left, with a small Cupid hovering at her shoulder.^[45][14] She wears a tunic and pallium (or palla).^[46] The Dioscuri appear on the obverse. The balance scale is a regular attribute of Aequitas ("Fair Measure"); the presence of Cupid marks the figure as a Venus.^[47]

Salomon Reinach thought it unlikely that the scale represented the power of Verticordia to bring balance to the passions, and considered it more generally to relate Venus to the zodiac sign of Libra, given the astrological preoccupations of the time,^[48] though in the late Republic Venus was more often associated with Taurus.^[49] While the cult of Verticordia is sometimes viewed as bringing equilibrium to the influence of Venus,^[50] countering her sexual force with the self-discipline of pudicitia, it may be a stretch to read the iconography of the coin as expressing that function.^[51][52]

The coin was issued by the moneyer Manius Cordius Rufus, and an identification as Verticordia is largely premised on an allusion to his family name, the gens Cordia.^[53][45][52] During this period, Julius Caesar was claiming Venus as his divine ancestor, and the goddess was prominent in his iconography under various cult titles, particularly Venus Genetrix, Venus as the mother of the Roman people. Although Verticordia expresses the more conservative values that Genetrix embodies,^[54] given that new instantiations of Venus were in vogue, no compelling reason emerges for Verticordia to have been revived at this time.^[55] Michael Crawford thought the figure of Venus more likely to be of the same type as the statue installed that year in the Temple of Venus Genetrix.^[56]

The narratives that explain the founding of Venus Verticordia's cult blend history and myth, as is characteristic of Roman mythology and its focus on human actions within a divine order that supports the Roman state.^[57] Ancient sources indicate that both the dedication of the statue and the building of the temple were religious responses during a time of military and social crisis.^[58]

In the latter 3rd century BC, following a consultation with the Sibylline Books, it was determined that a statue of Venus Verticordia was required in response to the impudicitia of Roman matrons.^[19] Legislative concern about the immoderate behavior of matrons, or more precisely their ability to control wealth, was expressed around this time in the passage of the lex Oppia of 216 BC, a sumptuary law that sought to restrict the amount of gold a woman could own as well as the ways she could display her wealth.^[59] The wealth of women would have increased through inheritance as losses in war reduced the male population  – thousands had died in the Battle of Cannae in a single day that year.^[60] At a time of prodigies and moral panic, as well as the diminished presence of men in everyday life, Roman women throughout this century were called on to participate more visibly in state religion, and doing so required them to move in relative freedom about the city, either in carriages or on foot accompanied by numerous attendants.^[61] Aemilia, the wife of Scipio Africanus, arguably Rome's greatest general in the Second Punic War, was transported in an ornate carriage and employed implements of gold and silver in carrying out women's rites.^[62]

This greater public role put stress on conservative Roman society that the Oppian limitations on modes of mobility and wealth, caused in part by displays of religious piety, were meant to confine to the purpose of religious cultivation.^[63] The Oppian law was related to other extraordinary efforts in 216 BC toward restraining women who had been engaged in war protests and demonstrations in the Forum Romanum following Cannae.^[64] When Cato the Elder argued twenty years later against repealing the lex Oppia, he railed that women being given free rein to ride horses or drive carriages was a perversion, since the ungovernable nature of women required them to submit to the yoke of customs and laws even when they thought them unjust.^[65] His argument failed on the grounds that women were part of Rome's progress toward civilization, and the law was repealed.^[66]

The statue of Venus Verticordia was perhaps intended "to rebuke women who had formed 'irregular liaisons'" when their husbands or other men who held guardianship (tutela) over them were away at war.^[67] From a list of one hundred matrons, presumably of senatorial rank, who were religiously and morally eligible to dedicate the statue, ten were chosen by lot.^[17] After some sort of "real virtue contest" among the ten finalists,^[68] the women themselves chose Sulpicia for the honor.^[69]

Sulpicia is most likely historical, though she became a legendary figure.^[70] Valerius Maximus says that she was the daughter of a Paterculus and the wife of a Quintus Fulvius Flaccus, presumably the consul of 237 BC.^[71] She is described in superlatives as sanctissima ("most holy"),^[72] elevated above all others in castitas ("purity", both religious and sexual),^[72] and pudicissima, of utmost sexual integrity.^[73] The French sociologist Jean-Claude Kaufmann imagined Sulpicia herself as the model for the statue,^[74] since she embodied the desired virtues.^[75]

About a hundred years after the statue was dedicated, as tensions in North Africa were mounting for the Iugurthine War, the Temple of Venus Verticordia was built in response to a prodigy (prodigium). The protagonist in the story was a virgin, Greek parthenos in Plutarch and virgo in Latin sources, named as Elbia, Elvia, or Helvia. Plutarch (early 2nd century AD) says Elbia was out horseback riding when she was struck dead by a lightning bolt. She was found naked, with her dress (chiton) pulled up as if on purpose, and with her shoes, rings, and hair bindings (kekryphalos) torn off and scattered around. Her mouth was open, and the tongue was hanging out. Her horse was also found dead and stripped of its trappings. The haruspices (manteis)^[76] immediately connected the incident to a disgrace among the Vestals, probably issuing their response in September 114 BC,^[76] and an investigation was launched.^[d][77]

Julius Obsequens (late 4th/early 5th century AD), who compiled a collection of prodigies and drew on now-lost parts of the Augustan-era historian Livy's work, dates the incident to the consulship of Manius Acilius Balbus and Gaius Porcius Cato in 114 BC. He identifies the virgin as the daughter of a Publius Elvius, a member of the equestrian order. While Plutarch has her out riding alone and her body later discovered, in Obsequens' account she is traveling in the company of her father from the Roman Games to Apulia when the incident occurs in the ager Stellas, the Stellate Plain.^[76][e] She is left dead by the lightning strike, with her garment pulled up to expose her genitals and her tongue hanging out, as if fire had flashed from the "lower places" (per inferiores locos) to her mouth. While the death of the horse is not explicitly reported, its trappings (ornamenta) are said to have been scattered about.^[f]

In the version of the Christian writer Orosius (died ca. 420 AD), the equestrian Lucius Helvius was returning to Apulia from Rome with his wife and daughter when a storm struck the traveling party. Seeing that his daughter was upset by the storm, he decided to leave the vehicles behind and to proceed more quickly on horseback to seek shelter. But when the girl rode into the middle of the traveling party, she was struck dead by lightning, which caused her clothing to be pulled off without being torn – the bindings at her breast and feet were undone, and her necklaces and rings yanked off. She was left lying "in an obscene manner", naked but with no injury apparent, and her tongue hanging out "just a little". As with Plutarch, the horse is struck dead too, and its bridle and harnessing unfastened and scattered. The wife, unmentioned in the other versions, plays no role in the story.^[g]

Outside the taking of official auspices, an unsought sign that violated the predictable orderliness of the physical world occasioned alarm. The prodigium was a sign of divine displeasure, and the religious offense that provoked it had to be identified and expiated. The frequency of recorded prodigies seems to have been especially intense during the Second Punic War, and these were often accompanied by lightning, a speciality of Etruscan divination.^[78] The forensic techniques for interpreting lightning accounted for elements such as the direction from which the strike came and what kind of damage it left. For instance, Jullius Obsequens traced the path of the strike from "lower places" to the mouth – lightning from below being one of the standard signifying types.^[79] The scattering of the horse trappings, according to Obsequens, was a sign that pointed to the involvement of the equestrian order.^[h]

The Sibylline Books were consulted, and an official pronouncement (responsum) formalized the accusation against members of the equestrian order along with three Vestals in the disgrace, which Obsequens labels infamia. The consultation with the Sibylline Books may have been the source for the epithet Verticordia, modeled after the Greek cult of Aphrodite Apostrophia, who turned away (from apo-, "away," and stroph-, "turn") disordered acts of sexuality.^[80][81] Danielle Porte saw apotropaism in the powers of Venus Verticordia, as can be read into the prodigy's imagery of the protruding tongue characteristic of gorgoneia and female genitalia exposed as in the anasyrma skirt-lifting gesture.^[82][83][i] Plutarch writes of anasyrma by women as a gesture of repelling a besieging enemy.^[85] In the telling of the Roman poet Ovid, the beautiful virgin Medusa becomes the frightening gorgon after she is raped by Poseidon/Neptune.^[86] The connection between the wrathful power of Medusa's gaze and the deflecting gesture of anasyrma is expressed in a complex of myths encompassing Medusa and Baubo, who lifted her skirts in impudent mockery and warded off Demeter's fury over the rape of her daughter Persephone.^[87] Reinach uniquely argued that Verticordia was herself une ravageuse ("ravager"), taking the verb verto to mean overturning or upsetting hearts, based on Latin usage at the time of the cult's initial founding. Hence the temple was a way to appease a seething goddess who caused disordered behavior that affected women.^[88]

The story of the Vestals that caused the founding of Venus Verticordia's temple is "extraordinary" in the scope of its crimen incesti (criminal unchastity), involving three Vestals in acts of unprecedented sexual excess.^[90] Among the duties of the public priesthood of the Vestals was religious maintenance: of the eternal flame of the virgin goddess Vesta; of a state storehouse of archives and artifacts such as the Palladium; and of their own chastity – all regarded as not merely symbols but actual guarantors of Roman security and power. A Vestal's castitas differed from the pudicitia of a matron in that, like Rome's walls, her body was not to be breached.^[91] The temple was open to the public during the day, but at night men were forbidden even to enter.^[92] Even one incident of unchastity (incestum) involving a single Vestal spelled instability or a pending disaster for Rome.^[93] The Vestal who violated her vow not only had done something morally and religiously wrong but was a criminal and a traitor.^[94] The execution of a condemned Vestal was simultaneously an expiation of a religious pollution and a sentence for treason.^[95]

The prodigy of the horse-riding virgin was linked to three Vestals – from three illustrious families, the gentes Marcia, Aemilia, and Licinia – committing repeated acts of sexual misconduct with several members of the equestrian order.^[96][93][77] The Greek historian Cassius Dio, writing in the early 3rd century AD, gives an account "of orgiastic proportion".^[93] Marcia had discreetly taken one equestrian (often translated as "knight", though not a precise equivalent to the Roman social rank) as her lover, but Aemilia and Licinia carried on with several serially, telling each man he was the only one. Then the two women started having sex with anyone who knew about it, so as to implicate them and ensure their silence under the threat of the execution that awaited any man who violated a Vestal. Finally they progressed to hosting group sex together and, in an act of quasi-incest in the modern sense, traded off sex with each other's brother.^[97]

The trial before the pontiffs started in December 114 BC; the proceedings have been described as "exceptional and no doubt politically motivated."^[98] According to Asconius, only Aemilia was condemned, and the other two were absolved;^[j] however, the people (populus), unsatisfied with the verdict, demanded a quaestio, a specially convened tribunal.^[100] The decision of the pontiffs was reversed, and all three Vestals were condemned^[96] to the ritual death prescribed for incestum. Although the incident has sometimes been seen as a clash between the senatorial and equestrian orders, not all the men implicated were equestrians, and the political utility of the "religious hysteria" generated during this time seems to have resided in the ability to challenge the judgment and authority of the pontifex maximus and to censure the College of Pontiffs as a whole.^[101] Popularist politics may have been in play in rebuking an elite for the abuse of privilege.^[102]

Because of the magico-religious aura of the Vestals, trials involving them often took on the character of witch hunts in the literal sense; however, the attendant moral panic in Rome was directed not at the socially disadvantaged but at the most elite women: the Vestal Virgins, who in this period came only from upper-class families, and matronae, respectably married women of the propertied classes, perceived as conspiring amongst themselves.^[103] The guilt and behaviors of the Vestals may have been exaggerated,^[104][105] or they may have been genuinely rebelling against the strictures of their office at a time when Roman women in general were pushing against the boundaries of traditional roles.^[106] In explaining the Temple of Venus Verticordia, the Augustan poet Ovid blames a general decline in pudicitia in his great-grandfathers' day.^[14]

The founding of Verticordia's temple and the punishment of the Vestals for sacrilegious inchastity were deemed insufficient to avert the panic, and these expiations were supplemented by a rare human sacrifice in ancient Rome — of two couples, one Greek and the other Celtic. Livy calls the practice "hardly Roman", but it seems to have been the second time this particular rite was enacted, the first carried out during the Hannibalic War.^[107] According to Plutarch, it was the last human sacrifice carried out in Rome.^[108]

The feast day of Venus took place on 1 April (the Kalends). Verticordia may have supplanted or been a refinement of an older form of Venus originally honored on the Kalends,^[110] and she shares the day with Fortuna Virilis, an older instantiation of the goddess Fortuna whose origins are unknown.^[111] The Kalends of April was one of three days during the year when a woman expected to receive a gift from her male romantic partner, the other two being her birthday and the Sigillaria in December.^[112][113] No games (ludi) were held as they were for many other religious festivals.^[114][115]

The whole month of April, Latin Aprilis, was under the guardianship (tutela) of Venus,^[116] and Ovid and others took Aphrodite, the name of her Greek counterpart, as the origin of the word Aprilis.^[117] The more common view among the Romans was that Aprilis derived from the verb aperire, "to open", according to Verrius Flaccus because it was the month when "fruits and flowers and animals and seas and lands do open".^[118] April and June were the most propitious months for weddings, as they were presided over by Venus and then Juno as a goddess of marriage.^{[citation needed]} The April religious calendar was dominated by female rites, with major festivals for Magna Mater ("Great Mother") and Ceres as well as days for Venus.^[119] The Kalends is not named as the Veneralia until the Calendar of Filocalus in AD 354, which illustrates the month of April with a scene from the theatrical ludi of Magna Mater.^[120]

The most detailed source on the rites of Venus on 1 April is the Kalends of April section in Book 4 of Ovid's poem about the Roman calendar, the Fasti,^[121] but the word Verticordia is metrically impossible in elegiac couplets and thus can't be used as an epithet for Venus in the poem.^[122] Ovid refers to Verticordia, however, in a line that plays on the etymology of the epithet: inde Venus verso nomina corde tenet,^[123] "and from her change of heart Venus holds her title."^[124]

Bronze statuettes of a diademed Venus with the loose locks of the Anadyomene type: at left, jewelled from Baalbek, Roman Africa (1st–2nd century AD); at right, a pudica pose (ca. 150 AD, National Archaeological Museum, Florence)

According to Ovid, the cult image of Venus was bathed and redressed in the ritual act of lavatio.^[125] The goddess's rich adornments and gold necklaces were removed, and after she had been washed head to toe and polished dry, she was decked with not only her jewellery but also fresh roses and other flowers.^[126] Rose adornment was also part of the Vinalia, the wine festival on 23 April^[127] when Venus Erycina was celebrated. Ovid is the only source for Verticordia's lavatio, and the earliest for the bathing of the cult statue of the Magna Mater, which was carried to the river Almo during her festival 4–10 April, the Megalensia.^[128] Statue-bathing was not characteristic of early Roman religion; it may have served a practical purpose that was ritualized to preserve the sanctity of the image, or even been reconceptualized as an annual cleansing of offenses committed against the goddesses.^[13]

On the Kalends, matrons and brides were to supplicate^[129] Verticordia, seeking physical beauty, socially approved behaviors, and a good reputation,^[k] while women of lesser standing (mulieres humiliores) celebrated Fortuna Virilis^[130] by burning incense.^[131] The celebrants of Verticordia bathed communally, crowned in wreaths of myrtle,^[132] a plant especially associated with Venus and eroticism but not used in bridal wreaths.^[133] Ovid explains the origin (aetion) of myrtle-wearing with a brief version of the myth of Venus Anadyomene rising naked from the sea, recognizable as such in the poem by the "hair-drying pose" he describes.^[134] As she is wringing out her dripping hair on the shore, she becomes aware of a rowdy band of satyrs watching her.^[135] Unlike the usual myth in which an enraged goddess punishes the man who has seen her,^[136][l] Ovid's Venus simply covers herself with myrtle and goes about her pleasurable business.^[145] "Nakedness, baths, and female sexuality" form a kind of "expressive module" for the holiday.^[146] "The nakedness that lies at the center of this celebration is no taboo," Alessandro Barchiesi observed of Ovid's reassembling of the religious materials, but "is a public gesture" emulating the ancestress of the Romans as Aeneadae,^[m] descendants of Aeneas, son of Venus.^[149]

Participants also emulated Venus in consuming cocetum,^[151] a slurry of poppy seed, milk, and honey that served a ceremonial purpose similar to the kykeon of the Eleusinian Mysteries. The festival of Ceres – Greek Demeter for whom poppy was emblematic – began 12 April with games and performances in the Circus Maximus and concluded 19 April with the Cerialia.^{[152] [153][154]} The poppy beverage may have helped relax or sedate anxious virgin brides,^{[155][156][157]} or had an aphrodisiac^[158] or more strongly narcotic or hallucinatory effect, depending on the opiate content of the poppy.^[159] Ovid offers another origin story for brides consuming the cocetum, saying that Venus herself drank it on her wedding night.^[151] But he undermines an image of Venus as a model wife with the sexuality of Venus as a woman, framing her feast day with reminders of Mars, her regular consort to whom she was not married. Ovid repeats in the Fasti a double entendre he had made in his Ars Amatoria ("The Art of Love") on how Mars "hooks up" with Venus on the Kalends of April, the day that joins his month of March to hers.^[160] On this day, Venus drank the cocetum to endure her wedding night, forced to marry the unattractive but eager bridegroom Vulcan.^{[161][162][163][n]} Her son Aeneas, father of the Roman people, was born from her adulterous desire for the mortal Anchises.^[165]

The mutual desire of Mars and Venus being fundamental to the Roman state,^[166] their allegorization as the generative couple of Rome's founding, coupled with the high value Romans placed on a marriage between well-matched partners, eventually led to conceiving of Mars and Venus as married.^[167] The role of Venus Verticordia was not to inhibit sexuality but to promote libido within marriage, which Cicero described as "the seedbed of the republic" (seminarium rei publicae).^[168] About nine months after Venus's feast day on 1 April, the Carmentalia that celebrated the goddess of childbirth^[169] was celebrated for all women giving birth, and was a festival unusually without social stratification.^[170]

Ovid's artistic intermingling of Verticordia and Fortuna Virilis and his social commentary on the division of the celebrants is "notoriously controversial"^[171] and "puzzlingly paradigmatic" as a historical source.^[172] The relation of the two goddesses is difficult to disentangle,^[o] and Venus and Fortuna in their varying manifestations had overlapping functions in early Roman religion, owing in part to their association in the legends of Servius Tullius, sixth king of Rome. The origins of Fortuna Virilis are no later than the 4th century BC, predating the dedication of Verticordia's statue,^[180] and Plutarch traces a temple of Fortuna Virilis back to Servius Tullius himself,^[181] to whom many such foundings were attributed.

The 1 April feast day was celebrated widely, perhaps universally, by Roman women, but ancient sources seem to indicate social segregation in what aspects they might participate in. The bathing and adornment of Verticordia's statue could involve only a limited number of women,^[182] and selectivity of merit was inherent in the establishment of her cult. The women who attended on her wore the respectable attire of the matron.

Women of lesser status attended to Fortuna Virilis, and then they – or perhaps all women^[p] – crowned themselves in myrtle like Venus and went to share a "fecundating" bath^[185] in public view of men,^[186] who watch as the satyrs did.^[187] Earlier in the Fasti, Ovid had used the word iuventus ("the youth" as a collective), which in this period often meant an elite troop of young men of the equestrian order, to refer to a band of satyrs subject to Venus.^[188] T. P. Wiseman conjectured that in the 4th century BC, the rites on the Kalends of April may even have involved men dressing as satyrs.^[189] The male gaze played an essential role in the rites of Fortuna Virilis and Venus Verticordia, though they were celebrated only by women – a marked contrast to most all-female cults, which excluded or religiously prohibited the presence of men.^[190]

In the late 4th century BC, public bathing might have taken place at the public pool (piscina publica), but the appearance of the women at the men's public baths has to be a later development, since these were not in use until the 2nd century BC.^[191] The name Fortuna Virilis means something closer to "Good Luck in Men" than "Manly Fortune", or "Lucky Guy" if the women's actions are meant as a "privileged exhibition" for the men^[187] – the women may be hesitant that taking off their clothes exposes physical imperfection, but that isn't what Fortuna Virilis lets men see.^[192][136] Ovid's contemporary Verrius Flaccus emphasizes that male desire is exposed as well at the baths, "because in them men are naked in that part of the body where the favor of women is desired".^[193]

By the early second century AD, the rituals of Fortuna Virilis seem to have been absorbed into the cult of Venus Verticordia.^[194] By late antiquity, the drinking of cocetum and practices associated with Fortuna Virilis appear to have fallen into disuse,^[195] but celebrations on the Kalends continued to serve the purpose of Verticordia in promoting conjugal life.^[196] The name Veneralia for the festival on 1 April first appears in AD 354 in the Calendar of Filocalus, the work of a Christian illustrator and chronographer that integrates Christian elements into the traditional Roman calendar.^[197] A temple of Venus, possibly that of Verticordia,^[198] was restored at Rome even in the latter 4th century, after Christian laws banning certain religious practices under the catchall label "paganism" were coming into effect.^[199]

As an example of how mythological imagery could be adapted by Christians,^[200] the bridal casket from the Esquiline Treasure, dating to around 380 AD, mirrors an image of Venus Anadyomene in depicting the bride, with a similar composition of the scene and the pose of the central figure. An inscription enjoins the newlyweds to live in Christ.^[196][201] Venus is attended by the marine thiasos that more commonly surrounds Poseidon-Neptune. A centaurotriton presents Venus with a convex mirror gripped like a shield as a servant holds up a similar but flat or concave mirror for the bride below.^[201][202] The Venus scene is framed by winged Cupids and the bride's toilette by peacocks.^[203]

The Veneralia may have been the setting Augustine of Hippo had in mind in a sermon on Mary and Martha, dated to AD 393, when he writes that "we" should not get carnally distracted by "banquets of Venus" (epulae venerales)^[q] but practice moderate behavior (modestia).^[205] Augustine advised forbearance, not passion, as a way to approach the secular banquet of Venus, which he seems to regard as "rather a respectable affair in 'celebration of a life of harmony and fullness'".^[206][207] The 6th-century antiquarian Ioannes Lydus, writing in Greek, says that women of higher rank had worshipped Aphrodite on 1 April "to achieve concord (homonoia) and a modest life",^[208] with no mention of Fortuna Virilis.

In the associations made among goddesses in the April book of the Fasti, Ovid's underlying theology is consonant with that of Varro, who wrote at the end of the Republic and into the reign of Augustus. For Varro, the apparent tensions among deities were dynamic functional alignments. Venus, Ceres, and Cybele were mother goddesses who were also concerned in their manifold ways with the chastity and virginity that Vesta embodied.^[211] The rape of Ceres' daughter Proserpina is a pivotal moment of transformation, "the essential union of male and female by violence"; Varro states flatly that "a woman does not cease to be a virgin without violence".^[212]

Venus herself "is the force of conjunction that leads to generation".^[213] The coniunctio (connection, union, conjunction) of Venus integrates the range of women's experiences; Vesta is concerned with virginity in isolation, the rites and myths of Ceres have no place for prostitutes, and matrons have little to do with Flora, whose festival ends the month of April and continues into May. But all women find a power in Venus, through whom the expiation of sexual excesses can occur.^[214] In presiding over the turning of the heart, Venus Verticordia is pivotal in negotiating a woman's own independent desire, either libido or the effort to remain intact apart from a man's desire, in relation to the realities of male violence and subjection of women.^[215][216]

In the month of Venus, on 23 April, a day comparable to the Greek Aphrodisia festival^[217] was devoted to Venus Erycina extra portam Collinam, "Venus of Eryx outside the Colline Gate" and hence outside the sacred boundary of Rome (pomerium) as foreign rites traditionally were. Sex workers (meretrices) attended while socially respectable women celebrated the same goddess with "cleaned up" rites at the Vinalia festival on the Capitoline.^[218] The lower-class women (mulieres humiliores) who celebrated Fortuna Virilis on the Kalends of April would have included prostitutes as well.^[218] Sarah Pomeroy believed that the humiliores comprised only prostitutes, but this is not standard usage of the word,^[219] and Ovid undermines even the usual social distinction between the humiliores and women of the upper social orders^{[218][220][r]} in the inclusivity of the 1 April festivities.^[222]

Venus Erycina was a Punic cult^[223] imported from Sicily, and her temple was built as the result of a wartime vow, most likely in 212 BC at the close of the Siege of Syracuse which gave Rome control of the island. At her temple on the Capitoline, Erycina was eventually assimilated to Venus Genetrix, Venus as the generative mother of the Roman people, a moral amelioration of Erycina that indicates "prostitution was not the only item in her portfolio."^[224] The development of Erycina's cult shows the counterbalancing of an ideation of sexual women as whores^[225] by advancing the more self-controlled form of sexuality (pudicitia) for women within marriage, which Verticordia also embodied.^{[223][226][225]}

The social separation between Fortuna Virilis and Venus Verticordia, and between the two temples of Venus Erycina, had played out earlier in similar dynamic tension as the Conflict of the Orders sought resolution.^[227] A patrician woman had married a plebeian and consequently was deemed ineligible to participate in the cult of Pudicitia Patricia, "Pudicitia for Patricians". In response, she established a shrine to Pudicitia Plebeia as an alternative for socially aspiring plebeians in 295 BC.^[228] Pudicitia was the public moral arena in which women competed as men did in virtus, "manly" excellence.^[229] Only univirae, married women who had been with only one man, could be admitted to either cult of Pudicitia, emphasizing a woman's success at the self-management of her own sexuality beyond social expectations or male desire.^[230] The shrines of both Pudicitia Plebeia and Venus Verticordia were established in response to prodigies at a time of crisis in the Roman state; it is a frequent pattern that repairing social disorder required the public demonstration of the sexual and moral integrity of Roman women.^[231]

The location of the Temple of Venus Verticordia in the Vallis Murcia also raises questions about her relation to the obscure goddess Murcia, the varied spelling of whose name led to her identification with Venus Murtea or Myrtea, "Venus of the Myrtle Grove".^[233][234]

Servius says that Verticordia's temple precinct (fanum) was near the Circus Maximus in a former myrtle grove,^[235] which was also the site of the Rape of the Sabine Women.^[236] As a pretext for the founding act of bride abduction, Romulus had invited the Sabine families to a festival in honor of the god named by Plutarch as Poseidon Hippios ("Horse Poseidon"), Latinized as Neptunus Equester ("Equestrian Neptune") and identified with the archaic god Consus. The underground altar of Consus was located at one of the two points of the Circus Maximus where the chariots turned, the metae Murciae, near the myrtle grove.^{[237][238][239]} In earliest times, the site was largely flooded by the Tiber river in April, a terrain supporting the conceptualization of Venus rising from the "sea" among the myrtles, but in the driest months, the area was devoted to horse races,^[240] especially in August, when Venus's second wine festival of the year was held on the 19th, two days before the horse-racing festival of Consus.^[241]

In the Ars Amatoria, Ovid had characterized the Sabine abduction as a crime^[242] of artless violence to "be redeemed … as a kind of ritual between the sexes."^[243] Livy and Dionysius have Romulus reassure the abducted virgins that the intention is marriage for the purpose of building society, not an outrage against their person.^[244] At the end of hostilities, both the Sabines and the newcomer Romans laid down their arms and used myrtle wands to purge their violence.^[245] Myrtle more broadly signified Venus as a force arising "not from mere longing but from some impulse of capture" or intention (mens),^[246][s] as indicated by the awarding of a wreath of Venus's myrtle to generals who earned an ovation.^[248][t] In an extended passage on myrtle, including several magico-medical uses, Pliny notes that rings crafted from myrtle twigs "virgin" to the touch of iron cure the swelling of genitals.^[249]

In Ovid's etiology of practices on the Kalends of April, Venus's use of myrtle wards off the potential for violence in the male gaze of the satyrs, mediating the sexual antagonism associated with the Vallis Murcia – the men can still look, but on Venus's terms.^[250][187] The myrtle is a screen that makes Venus safe (tuta), and by extension the women who wear her myrtle.^[136][187] The vatic poet of the Fasti is himself allowed to observe the rites of Venus and to speak of them only after the goddess "lightly touched his temples with myrtle".^[251]

The Greek equivalent of Verticordia, Aphrodite Apostrophia^[252] ("Aphrodite of Turning Away"^[u]) was complementary to Demeter Erinys.^[253] The April rites of Roman Ceres were not based on the primary Greek myth of Demeter^[254] – the abduction of her daughter Persephone to serve as the bride of Pluto – and yet Ovid chooses to narrate it at disproportionate length in his treatment of April in the Fasti.^[255] This choice may have been motivated by the complex nexus in Greek myth and cult between Demeter Erinys and Aphrodite Apostrophia.^[256] Demeter Erinys ("Furious Demeter") represents the rightful anger the goddess felt^[257] after she herself was raped during her search for her daughter, having turned herself into a mare to try to evade Poseidon only to have him transform into a stallion to mount her.^[v] Erinys is the drive for vengeance, rendered into lawfulness by Demeter Thesmophoros ("Bringer of Laws", thesmoi) who preserves family order and the state.^[260] Although Demeter's Thesmophoria is framed broadly as an all-female "fertility" festival, the second day became a "forum for crime detection and dispute resolution" pervaded by the complaint of the wronged goddess.^[261]

The animalizing potential of desire is "turned away" by Aphrodite Apostrophia (from apo-, "away" and strophein, "to turn") – so called because she diverted the human race from acting on desires that were contrary to nomos (ἐπιθυμίας τε ἀνόμου) and from unholy deeds (ἔργων ἀνοσίων).^[262] As examples of wrongly turned desire to be averted by Apostrophia, Pausanias cites the rape committed by Tereus, who cut out his victim's tongue so she couldn't speak; Phaedra, who tried to seduce her stepson and then accused him of rape when he spurned her;^[w] and the incestuous desire of Myrrha for her father, which produced the beautiful youth Adonis, unsatisfactorily loved by both Aphrodite and Persephone.^[x] In his treatment of Venus Verticordia, Ovid averts his own eyes from these kinds of stories and sublimates the historical circumstances of her cult founding: he omits the prodigy of the scorched equestrian virgin Helvia, the Vestals' incestum that led to the founding of Verticordia's temple, and the horror of human sacrifice as joint expiation, as if complicit in the cover-up of Venus.^[264]

Incest plays a role in one version of how the Roman Bona Dea, whose rites seem most comparable to the Thesmophoria, became a goddess.^[265] In most tellings, she is deified after her husband, Faunus, beats her with a myrtle branch – in one account, to death^[266] – when he finds her drinking wine, but Macrobius has her as his daughter, whom he beats with myrtle when she refuses sex even though he has plied her with wine. In the hands of Faunus, who in the later tradition is often depicted with satyr-like features, the myrtle of Venus becomes an instrument for "excessive erotic desire".^[267] Both men and myrtle were banned from Bona Dea's rites,^[268] and her temple was situated on the slope of the Aventine,^[269] above the Valley of Myrtle where the "horsey" Neptune had presided over the abduction of the Sabine virgins.

In Verticordia's mythology, the threat of bestial sexuality is represented by the satyrs in Ovid's account of Venus's bath,^[270] and by the prodigy of the horse-riding virgin, whose body is found with signs that ordinarily might be interpreted as rape.^[256] The German philologist Carl Koch suggested that the Sibylline consultation calling for a temple to Venus Verticordia might have directly prescribed the model of Apostrophia, as was the case with some other transferrals of Greek or other deities to Rome.^[81]

The feast day of Venus Verticordia was one of two April holidays featuring the public nudity of women, the second being stage performances at the Floralia that started at the end of the month and continued into May.^[271] For the Floralia, however, the bodies of entertainers and prostitutes were on display; on the Kalends, even respectable matrons removed the garments that marked them as such, the long dress (stola) that covered them to their feet and the headbands (vittae) that bound their hair.^[272] Valerius Maximus attributed a kind of inviolability to the stola, stating that it was not to be subjected to the touch of an "alien" hand^[y] – meaning someone outside the family – even if the matron came under arrest.^[273] The unwilling removal of the protective garment would be a violation, but its willing removal and the reclaiming of the nude body held power: "Like the Gorgon's eye, it can paralyze or protect."^[274] Although female nudity among the Archaic and Classical Greeks had been taboo, "respectable female nudity" was imported into Italy via the Etruscans and took the form of Hellenistic Aphrodite.^[275]

The Venus Pudica statuary type displays the goddess naked, and the placement of her hands is not obviously defensive but rather instructs the viewer toward the erogenous zones of the female body.^{[276][277][278]} The sometime presence of a cloth or drapery is ambiguous as to whether Pudica has just removed her garment or is about to put it on, and in some versions, such as the Mazarin Venus (at the top of this article), suggests a striptease.^[279] The ancient calendars that illustrate April with a statue of Venus show her in the pudica or anadyomene poses.^[280] The apparent erasure of social rank in emulating the nude Venus was renegotiated by the practice of wearing jewellery in the baths, as modeled by the bejewelling of these nude statues and documented by archaeological finds in the drains.^[281]

Both the Venus Anadyomene and Pudica types are associated with rising from the water, sometimes indicated by a hydria (water vessel)^[283] or dolphin, with bathing a reenactment of the goddess's birth from the sea. Ovid's description of Venus with dripping hair for the Kalends of April may have been inspired by a painting in the anaydomene pose that Augustus had exhibited in the Temple of the Deified Julius.^[284] Pudica, however, is well coiffed. Roman matrons were not portrayed with the loose, wet locks of Anadyomene,^[285] which released an eroticism that might not be fully under control; elaborately bound-up hairstyles were not simply ornamental but "upright" in the moral sense.^[286][121] The polymath Varro said that the piled-up hairstyle of Roman matrons was called a tutulus from the word tutus, "safe", and was also nicknamed an arx, like the citadel of the city^[121] – just as functionally the cult of Verticordia was established for matrons to safeguard the city after the Vestal Virgins failed in that role.^[287] And just as women reenacted the role of Venus in the rites of 1 April,^[288] they were portrayed quite literally as Venus in sculpture, with their own portrait head placed on a conventional body type of the goddess^[289][290] – a costly form of self-expression available only to those who could afford it, from the wives of emperors to successful freedwomen.^[291] Although nude, their portraits exhibit "flawless reserve and self-possession".^[292]

• Venus Verticordia (1868), an allegorical Pre-Raphaelite painting by Dante Gabriel Rossetti
• Dea Viriplaca, the husband-pleasing goddess