| Sezon | Półfinał (1. mecz) | Półfinał (rewanż) | Finał |
| 2004/2005 | Lincoln City 1-0 Macclesfield Town
Northampton Town 0-0 Southend United | Macclesfield Town 1-1 Lincoln City
Southend United 1-0 Northampton Town | Lincoln City 0-2 Southend United |
| 2005/2006 | Lincoln City 0-1 Grimsby Town
Wycombe Wanderers 1-2 Cheltenham Town | Grimsby Town 2-1 Lincoln City
Cheltenham Town 0-0 Wycombe Wanderers | Grimsby Town 0-1 Cheltenham Town |
| 2006/2007 | Bristol Rovers 2-1 Lincoln City
Shrewsbury Town 0-0 Milton Keynes Dons
| Lincoln City 3-5 Bristol Rovers
Milton Keynes Dons 1-2 Shrewsbury Town | Bristol Rovers 3-1 Shrewsbury Town |
| 2007/2008 | Darlington 2–1 Rochdale
Wycombe Wanderers 1–1 Stockport County | Rochdale 2–1 Darlington
(Rochdale wygrało 5-4 w rzutach karnych)
Stockport County 1–0 Wycombe Wanderers | Rochdale 2–3 Stockport County |
| 2009/2010 | Dagenham & Redbridge 6–0 Morecambe
Aldershot Town 0–1 Rotherham United | Morecambe 2–1 Dagenham & Redbridge
Rotherham United 2–0 Aldershot Town | Dagenham & Redbridge 3–2 Rotherham United |
| 2010/2011 | Torquay United 2-0 Shrewsbury Town
Stevenage 2-0 Accrington Stanley | Shrewsbury Town 0-0 Torquay United
Accrington Stanley 0-1 Stevenage | Stevenage 1-0 Torquay United |
| 2011/2012 | Crewe Alexandra 1-0 Southend United
Cheltenham Town 2-0 Torquay United | Southend United 2-2 Crewe Alexandra
Torquay United 1-2 Cheltenham Town | Cheltenham Town 0-2 Crewe Alexandra |
| 2012/2013 | Bradford City 2–3 Burton Albion
Northampton Town 1–0 Cheltenham Town | Burton Albion 1–3 Bradford City
Cheltenham Town 0–1 Northampton Town | Bradford City 3–0 Northampton Town |
| 2013/2014 | Burton Albion 1–0 Southend United
York City 0–1 Fleetwood Town | Southend United 2–2 Burton Albion
Fleetwood Town 0–0 York City | Burton Albion 0–1 Fleetwood Town |
| 2014/2015 | Plymouth Argyle 2–3 Wycombe Wanderers
Stevenage 1–1 Southend United | Wycombe Wanderers 2–1 Plymouth Argyle
Southend United 3–1 Stevenage
(po dogrywce)
| Wycombe Wanderers 1–1 Southend United
(Southend wygrało 7-6 w rzutach karnych) |
| 2015/2016 | Portsmouth 2–2 Plymouth Argyle
AFC Wimbledon 1–0 Accrington Stanley | Plymouth Argyle 1–0 Portsmouth
Accrington Stanley 2–2 AFC Wimbledon
(po dogrywce)
| AFC Wimbledon 2–0 Plymouth Argyle |
| 2016/2017 | Blackpool 3–2 Luton Town
Carlisle United 3–3 Exeter City | Luton Town 3-3 Blackpool
Exeter City 3-2 Carlisle United | Blackpool 2-1 Exeter City |
| 2017/2018 | Lincoln City 0-0 Exeter City
Coventry City 1-1 Notts County | Exeter City 3-1 Lincoln City
Notts County 1-4 Coventry City | Coventry City 3-1 Exeter City |
| 2018/2019 | Newport County 1-1 Mansfield Town
Tranmere Rovers 1-0 Forest Green Rovers | Mansfield Town 0-0 Newport County
(Newport County wygrało 5-3 w rzutach karnych)
Forest Green Rovers 1-1 Tranmere Rovers | Newport County 0–1 Tranmere Rovers
(po dogrywce)
|
| 2019/2020 | Colchester United 1-0 Exeter City
Northampton Town 0-2 Cheltenham Town | Exeter City 3-1 Colchester United
Cheltenham Town 0-3 Northampton Town | Exeter City 0–4 Northampton Town |
| 2020/2021 | Newport County 2-0 Forest Green Rovers
Tranmere Rovers 1-2 Morecambe | Forest Green Rovers 4-3 Newport County
(po dogrywce)
Morecambe 1-1 Tranmere Rovers | Morecambe 1-0 Newport County |
| 2021/2022 | Mansfield Town 2-1 Northampton Town
Swindon Town 2-1 Port Vale | Northampton Town 0-1 Mansfield Town
Port Vale 1-0 Swindon Town
(Port Vale wygrało 6-5 w rzutach karnych)
| Mansfield Town 0-3 Port Vale |
| 2022/2023 | Salford City 1-0 Stockport County
Bradford City 1-0 Carlisle United | Stockport County 2-1 Salford City
(Stockport County wygrało 3-1 w rzutach karnych)
Carlisle United 3-1 Bradford City | Carlisle United 1-1 Stockport County
(Carlisle United wygrało 5-4 w rzutach karnych) |
| 2023/2024 | Crawley Town - Milton Keynes Dons
Crewe Alexandra - Doncaster Rovers | Milton Keynes Dons - Crawley Town
Doncaster Rovers - Crewe Alexandra | |
French
Deutsch